\"Writing.Com
*Magnify*
Printed from https://writing.com/main/profile/reviews/jim-d/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/41
Review Requests: ON
3,280 Public Reviews Given
3,328 Total Reviews Given
Review Style
Casual for the most part. I will point out errors I see and offer suggested corrections. I like to focus on the content and formatting of the item. I love providing helpful comments and feedback that may improve the item if acted on.
I'm good at...
I like to provide suggestions to the author on things I see that may need a second look. I'm not afraid to do a little research to verify a poem's format, or the contents of a story (if requested).
Favorite Genres
Mystery, Horror, Sci-Fi, Comedy, and Suspense
Least Favorite Genres
Honestly, I will read anything if asked. I just prefer those listed above.
Favorite Item Types
Short stories, novellas, books (though a review of that may take days/weeks due to my schedule), Poetry of any format.
Least Favorite Item Types
I find non-structured poetry difficult to review, unless there is a short disclaimer about this non-structure that would help in understanding the reason it's in that particular format.
I will not review...
I'm not interested in Vore, In and Out's, Growing/Shrinking, or other items that are similar to one of these.
Public Reviews
Previous ... 37 38 39 40 -41- 42 43 44 45 46 ... Next
1001
1001
Review of Hallow - what?  Open in new Window.
Review by Sum1 Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with I.N.K.E.D.  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.5)
Dear Just Loti,
         I saw your suitcase on the Anniversary Review page, and thought I'd drop in for a visit. Happy 9th WDC Anniversary!

         It doesn't sound like you have much of a Halloween that first night. *Frown* Shame on them for giving you those potatoes! This is a good story though, I could almost feel your energy and desire to go trick-or-treating. I liked how you looked up to your 12 year old cousin, I was much the same way when I was about that age. I guess I just can't imagine going trick or treat in a logging camp though. I do have a little feedback for you.



Title: Very cute, and perfect for this story.


Description: Three words, but you don't need to say more if you ask me. *Smile*


Grammar/Spelling: I noticed no errors



Rough spots?:

1. I looked at her in horror. "Do we really have to?" It seemed so mean. What would Mom say if we did something nasty to someone? Every other paragraph is indented, but this one is not.

2. I envisioned a chocolate ball or a popcorn ball
or even a candied apple.
On the webpage for the story, this looks to have an extra hard return in it after 'ball'. I stretched the window out wide, and the line remained below ball no matter what.



Overall Impressions: A very cute story of your first Halloween. I loved the children, one could almost see them going from house to house for this first Halloween. Well done!


Sum1

** Image ID #1795794 Unavailable **
1002
1002
Review by Sum1 Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
*Candleb*HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY FROM "Anniversary Reviews ~ Summer BreakOpen in new Window.*Candlev*


Walkinbird,
         I saw your suitcase on the Anniversary Review page, and thought I'd drop in for a visit. Happy 8th WDC Anniversary!

         This is a very good story, well written with a flow that kept me interested throughout. What I liked most was the slang you used, at least to me it was slang. Maybe it was Ben and Paula mimicking Billy's child speech, but I liked how you conveyed that. I was left with one question though (probably more than one, but I can only think of one right now). Why did the monsters in the dark suddenly start eating light, and why/how did they manage to eat the light from the stars? Just my mind, asking questions,,,,


Sum1

*Rainbowl*WDC POWER RAIDER*Rainbowr*


** Image ID #1795794 Unavailable **
1003
1003
Review by Sum1 Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with I.N.K.E.D.  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.0)
*Candleb*HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY FROM "Anniversary Reviews ~ Summer BreakOpen in new Window.*Candlev*


Dear ILove2Write,
         I saw your suitcase on the Anniversary Review page, and thought I'd drop in for a visit. Happy 4th WDC Anniversary!

         There are many ways to tell the story of someone's life, you've chosen to tell yours by referencing your faith. It's not apparent at the beginning, but is revealed to the reader slowly. It flows very nicely, and keeps the reader's interest throughout. If I may be so bold, I do have a little feedback for you on it.



Title: Very nice for this story.


Description: I'm a firm believer that the description should be used to entice a potential reader in to read this. You are allowed 90 characters, so tell the potential read why this is a story we just have to read.


Grammar/Spelling: I know that as a Writer's Cramp entry, you wrote this quickly, and had little time to edit it. I'm also pretty sure that the contest is over now, so you may want to look this over a little bit. Specific comments are below under 'Rough Spots'.


Characters: The only real character in this story is you. We didn't learn much about you really, but then, this is a story about your life, told from a distant point of view.



Rough spots?:

1. I complained, I had imbibed too much of the fruits of the fields and orchards along the way and become heavy. The last two words don't make sense when read with the rest of this sentence. I think you may have meant 'my load became heavy'.

2. But you come to a point when you chose that cottage over traveling on the road. I think you meant 'choose'. If you use chose, then it should read, 'But you came to a point...' come is present tense, chose is past.

3. The things I become accustom to obtaining at will were taken away. You need the word 'had' between I, and become.

4. Often call out a warning and an entreaty to turn and chose a road like mine. This sentence should start with the word I.



Overall Impressions: A good story about the road we travel in our lives, filled with the choices we make and the rewards we receive.


Sum1

** Image ID #1795794 Unavailable **
1004
1004
Review by Sum1 Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.0)
Dear MissKimStar,
         I saw your suitcase on the Anniversary Review page and thought I'd drop in for a visit. Happy 6th WDC Anniversary!

         Your poem asks a lot of questions that I think many people have asked themselves. You do a nice job in asking them, and bringing thoughts to mind that have been unspoken. It is free verse with no discernible rhyme or rhythm, but it's message is plainly clear. I do have a little feedback for you about it.



Title: This is good, it made me want to read this poem.


Description: Your description should be written to entice readers to come in and read this. We already know it's a poem, you've labeled it as such, so tell us in 90 characters why we should read this. I'm not sure what you might want to say here, but lure us in, MAKE us want to read this. *Bigsmile*



Rhyme/Rhythm: This is free verse, so I won't comment on rhythm/rhyme.



General Comments:

1. Why from them we run? I wonder why you worded this line this way. It is only five syllables long, while the line before it is seven syllables, and the line after is eleven. I know it's free verse, but even free verse can read what I call 'clumsy', and at this point, it does. Maybe this would work for you. "Why do we run from them?" One more syllable is all, but it seems to read better.

2. And people dying from Aids are know as outcast. I think you meant known, not know.

3. In re-reading it, it does have a nice rhyme to it. *Smile*

4. I think you could mention how the world was when you were younger, people helping each other, we cared, we loved. This would be a nice ending, if you added it to the last verse.




Overall impressions: Overall, a lovely poem that describes the world today, and how we have become a WIIFM (What's In It For Me?)race. Well done.


Sum1

*Rainbowl*WDC POWER RAIDER*Rainbowr*


** Image ID #1795794 Unavailable **
1005
1005
Review of Sandcastles  Open in new Window.
Review by Sum1 Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
Dear Farawayeyes,
         I saw your suitcase on the Anniversary Review page, and thought I'd drop in for a visit. Happy 5th WDC Anniversary!

         This is such a dangerous story here, one wrong move, one misstep, and he could have taken poor Anna. But it seemed as if he loved her as a child, yet longed for her as a woman too. I found myself happy that he was content to sit and admire her in whatever way he wanted, from a distance, but you did make me wonder what happened with the girl he watched in the spring. I saw a couple of things you may want to look at in this story though.



Title: Very good for this story.


Description: You left this open, as if maybe he would harm Anna, that made me read this story. Nice touch in that, piquing a curiosity.



Grammar: I noticed no errors.



General Comments:

1. Much like everything else, attracting me to this young fourth grader, her innocent laughter adds to this ever-growing appeal and enchantment she holds over me. I don't think you need the comma after else, it reads better without it.

2. Shattering her innocence and destroying the spectacle of it keeps me at bay. This sentence is incomplete. I would think that the words "The thought" before it makes it more complete.

3. Anna pushes the discarded sand aside towards the large pile she made originally earlier before clearing the space we’re constructing on now. This sentence is poorly worded. Originally and earlier right after one another do not make sense, nor does 'constructing on' now.




Overall impressions: A dark story about a man's 'love from a distance' for a little girl. Glad to see that it ended innocently enough.


Sum1


*Rainbowl*WDC POWER RAIDER*Rainbowr*


** Image ID #1795794 Unavailable **
1006
1006
Review by Sum1 Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
*Candleb*HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY FROM "Anniversary Reviews ~ Summer BreakOpen in new Window.*Candlev*


Dear Bhaskar,

         I saw your suitcase on the Anniversary Review page, and thought I'd drop in for a visit. Happy 10th WDC Anniversary!

         I think you have been truly blessed and lucky to live the life you have. I've traveled quite a bit, but mainly in the 'states', and a little in other parts of the world. This is a nice story about your adventure on top of an elephant. I think anyone who's been around at all would love a chance like that. I have to agree with you about the guns thought, we don't need to needlessly kill animals just to bolster our ego's. Your flow here is very good, and I'm going to go out on a limb here and say that English is most likely not your first language, yet this is written very well. If I may, I do have a little feedback for you.



Title: Very nice for this story.


Description: I was thinking it would be something a lot more embarrassing than just peeing from a treetop, but it all depends on your perspective, doesn't it. *Smile*



Grammar: Very good.


General Comments:

1. Some of your paragraphs are not separated by an extra space, while others are. This is not an issue, but I just thought I'd mention it.

2. Its the sounds and rhythm of the jungle. Its should be It's; as it is currently written, it is plural, but with the apostrophe in it, you're saying "It is the sounds and rhythm of the jungle."



Overall impressions: A wonderful story of an experience I think many would love to have. Nicely written, a good, relaxing read.


Sum1


*Rainbowl*WDC POWER RAIDER*Rainbowr*


** Image ID #1795794 Unavailable **
1007
1007
Review by Sum1 Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with I.N.K.E.D.  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Lyndi,
         I read this with some amount of amusement, and hope I'm not having a gray moment, because I've never heard of this "fry sauce". It made me smile, thinking about the politicians being involved in this, because it is believable! They (politicians) seem to poke their noses in everything today, I could see them involved in something like this. Your use of the word quote confused me, I've not seen it used when you use quotation marks for dialog. I think it might be a little better if you said, and I quote, "Pink s*** you smear on french fries."

         Overall though, this was a cute read. Thanks.

Sum1
1008
1008
Review of Cemetery  Open in new Window.
Review by Sum1 Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.0)
*Candleb*HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY FROM "Anniversary Reviews ~ Summer BreakOpen in new Window.*Candlev*


MilitaryGirl,
         I saw your suitcase on the Anniversary Review page, and thought I'd drop in for a visit. Happy 1st WDC Anniversary!

         I have to say I've never thought about writing about a cemetery, but now you've piqued my curiosity. *Smile* I love the idea that you go to a place like this and get inspiration to write.

         This has a nice flow to it with a rhyme scheme that seems very natural. It's rhythm is a little off in a couple of places, but that's very minor. If I may, I have a couple of comments for you.

1. I commented on the rhythm of the piece. Your syllable count varied from as low as four in the first line, to ten in one towards the end. Being off a little is fine if you ask me, even the span you have here is fine, but it depends on how far apart the difference is. In the last verse, your syllable count is 5-10-7-6. That broad jump in lines so close is what throws the rhythm off and makes the reader pause. In a previous verse, one of your lines has nine syllables, so going from nine to ten would be fine, even eight to ten is okay. But five in one line, and ten in the next really throws off the reader.

2. In the second verse, the second line states, "The stark quite of the dead". I think you meant quiet. However, if you do that, then you have quiet in two consecutive verses. (It was used in the first verse also). Obviously it's fine to have a word used more than once in a poem. But it detracts from the pleasurable read when they are so close together.

Overall, I found this to be a very nice read. Well done!


Sum1

*Rainbowl*WDC POWER RAIDER*Rainbowr*


** Image ID #1795794 Unavailable **
1009
1009
Review of The Storyteller  Open in new Window.
Review by Sum1 Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.0)
*Candleb*HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY FROM "Anniversary Reviews ~ Summer BreakOpen in new Window.*Candlev*


Thomas,
         I saw your suitcase on the Anniversary Review page, and thought I'd drop in for a visit. Happy 7th WDC Anniversary!

         It's not often you get to read a story like this these days. Few of us, myself included, could write the slang used in the dialog as well as you did. This man seemed to be able to hold his audience as long as he wished with the power of his words. I do have a little feedback for you about it.



Title: Excellent for this story.


Description: I'm all for nice, long descriptions that lure a reader in, but this one is fine as it stands.


General Comments:

1. They would play for hours, every Saturday and Sunday, and each would take turns telling about events that each of them already knew by heart. You use the word 'each' twice in this sentence. You could replace the first one with 'they', and still keep the same flow.

2. "Would anyone like some desert?" the waiter asked, looking around the table. Desert is an arid place, full of sand dunes and such. You meant dessert. This was done in at least three places in the story.

3. This is a personal opinion here, I'm not saying anything is wrong with your story, just voicing a thought. Throughout the story, Jim talks and talks. He stops when the waiter drops by, but other than that he dominates the story, and I know that's how it's supposed to be. But, it seemed as if there was no description of anything else. An example is provided below.

The other members of the party nodded in the affirmative, and the waiter removed a pad from the front pocket of his apron and looked at Jim. "Let's start with you. What can I get for ya?"

"Well, that there roast beef dinner sure looks mighty tasty. I reckon I'll have one of them," Jim says.

"How would you like your potatoes: baked, mashed, or fried?"

"There ain't nothing better than a good ole baked potato."

"Would you like soup or a side salad to start your meal?"

"What kind a soup ya'll got simmering today?"

"We have cream of broccoli and vegetable beef."

"Is yer vegetable beef all chunky like?"

"Yes sir."

"I'd sure be pleased with a steaming cup of that'n then."

"Anything to drink?"

"Just set a pitch black cup a coffee right down here in front o' me and make sure it don't get empty."

The waiter then took the orders of the other five people.
No one else spoke! There was no interaction between the waiter and the other five people. I know there would have been in real life, yet each time, Jim would talk to him, and you'd brush off the rest as if they were only there to listen to Jim. Unless they were ghosts, or figments of Jim's imagination....


Overall impressions: A nice story about a man who can captivate his audience.


Sum1


*Rainbowl*WDC POWER RAIDER*Rainbowr*

** Image ID #1795794 Unavailable **
1010
1010
Review by Sum1 Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with I.N.K.E.D.  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (3.5)
Aman,
         Sounds like you had a somewhat brutal first look at poverty. Sadly, it exists all over the world, even in America. Not as bad as what you saw, but it exists here. People live on the street in cardboard boxes, or sleep on park benches, even in the cold of winter. Obviously some of them don't live through the winter.

         This is a sad story you have here, but so true. Your English is much better than my Arabic would be, I know no other language than English. If I may, I have a small amount of feedback for you.

1. In the second paragraph, you write, "But one day, my day wanted to go to India." I think you meant dad.

2. Later on in that paragraph, you write, "People where live in dirt and on the road." I think you meant, "People were living in the dirt, and on the road." *Smile*

         You did well here with this, I always admire anyone who can read or write in multiple languages, I don't see how you can do that, so it amazes me.

Jim
1011
1011
Review by Sum1 Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.5)
*Candleb*HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY FROM "Anniversary Reviews ~ Summer BreakOpen in new Window.*Candlev*


Asylum_Goddess,
         I saw your suitcase on the Anniversary Review page, and thought I'd drop in for a visit. Happy 7th WDC Anniversary!

         I am never in favor of someone's death. Let me correct myself, I am rarely, very rarely, in favor of someone's death. For this man, I was. He's one of the few that I think the world is better off without. Your poem flows very nicely, I loved the questions you asked throughout the poem. The one thing you could change is your introduction. He's gone now, and someone will take his place, so you could change this a little to speak to terrorist leaders in general. Even though the poem speaks to "The buildings you shook", it could still apply to anyone, because other buildings will be shook, but not in the same manner as the twin towers.

         Overall, a nice smooth read, the rhythm and rhyme were good, they keep the reader involved throughout.

Sum1
1012
1012
Review by Sum1 Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.0)
Dollzell,
         Your poem is beautiful, one can see your love for this person pouring forth in every word. It is obvious this person holds a place in your heart, but it seems like you want that place closed for the most part. Yet still, there's a part of you that yearns for those wonderful times you shared, and I can't blame you, I'm the same way. You love this person, but it seems as if the romance has decayed, and now it's an everyday humdrum type of thing. If I may, I have a little feedback for you.


Title: I love your title. It calls to him, asking him to meet you. *Bigsmile*


Description: Yep, your description is good too. Don't we all wish for that second chance?



Rhyme/Rhythm:
         Your rhyme scheme is pretty good, but a couple just aren't perfect rhymes. I'm not counting that against you necessarily, because to me the story is more important than a perfect rhyme. But again/pain is a little stretch (read those lines aloud, and see what you think). But you/echo are far different. You has that 'U' sound, and echo has the 'O' sound.
         Your rhythm varied a little through the poem, going from fourteen syllables in one line, to ten in others. This is not too bad really, but sometimes in poetry, less is better. I will give you examples in my general comments.


General Comments:

1. My foolishness is coming back again and again
I already serve my time,give me no more pain.


I mentioned that this is not a perfect rhyme, but also said the story is more important. But, this could be modified slightly, and not change the tone of the poem.

My foolishness returns, like a revolving door
I've already served my time,give me pain no more.


Notice that two things were done. Door/more is a better rhyme, both lines are 12 syllables, and I took the liberty of changing the second line to read in the past, instead of the present.

2. A couple of your lines need a space between punctuation and the next word. An example would be "I'll slumber softly,for tonight no sorrow" This happens in a few places in your beautiful poem.

3. If only my heart had not fallen for you
Although no regrets,your words of love still echo


This rhyme is easily fixed, and to me it works, but I'm not sure if it's okay 'grammar-wise'.

If only my heart had not fallen for you so
Although no regrets,your words of love still echo


4. I listen before, now I'll listen no more Listen should be listened, since this poem describes a love that is in the past.

5. Why did I love you? only my heart can answer Only should be capitalized since the previous sentence ended in a question mark.

6. Yes,we had moved on with our lives and our families I mentioned that in poetry, sometimes less is better. I use this as an example. I think you can delete the second 'our' and not change anything in the poem's meaning. I also think that 'had' should be 'have' because now you are talking about your heart today.




Overall impressions: I really believe that love makes the world go round, and this poem is one of those that keeps our world spinning. Very nicely done!


Sum1

*Rainbowl*WDC POWER RAIDER*Rainbowr*


** Image ID #1795794 Unavailable **
1013
1013
Review by Sum1 Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with I.N.K.E.D.  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
*Candleb*HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY FROM "Anniversary Reviews ~ Summer BreakOpen in new Window.*Candlev*


David,
         I saw your suitcase on the Anniversary Review page, and thought I'd drop in for a visit. Happy 10th WDC Anniversary!

         Your story here left me smiling. Not at the end after finishing the read, but half way through when you first brought up 'The Beatles'. I have often thought that anyone who writes is guided in some way, I really think I am, so your story made sense to me, and made me smile. It is well written, flows nicely, and makes a lot of sense out of what we think of as 'fate'. I salute you sir!

Sum1

1014
1014
Review by Sum1 Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with I.N.K.E.D.  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.0)
*Candleb*HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY FROM "Anniversary Reviews ~ Summer BreakOpen in new Window.*Candlev*


Coffeebean,
         I saw your suitcase on the Anniversary Review page, and thought I'd drop in for a visit. Happy 5th WDC Anniversary!

         It's not often I get to read about someone's childhood, but I always love it when I do. Especially when it's about a memory that has sustained you throughout your life. I loved the flow, I could see you as a young boy, getting his new jeans each year. I have memories along those lines too, very nice ones. My only comment for you, would be to use the 'indent' command in WritingML to indent the first line of each paragraph. Nicely done!

Sum1
1015
1015
Review of That Old Fight  Open in new Window.
Review by Sum1 Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with I.N.K.E.D.  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
*Candleb*HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY FROM "Anniversary Reviews ~ Summer BreakOpen in new Window.*Candlev*


Dear Paradoxical,
         I saw you suitcase on the Anniversary Review page, and thought I'd drop in for a visit. Happy 2nd WDC Anniversary!

         This is a very interesting story here, to me it was about Adam and Eve discovering the Garden of Eden. But her name didn't match, so maybe not, unless we gave Eve her name (in the Bible) much later. This is a very good story though, I liked how you shifted scenes in it, it seems to me someone's dream. *Smile* I do have a little feedback for you though.


Title: Interesting title. I must have missed a key component in the story to not understand how it fits with the story.


Description: In the description, you mention a shouting match, but I don't recall ever reading about one.



Characters: Sophy and the unnamed bloke were rather shallow, but in a story this short, I'm not sure you can make them more real without detracting from the story content.



Rough spots?:

1. There were a couple of inconsistencies that hit me in this. She mentions that she can't get past the lake, pointing out that she has no legs. Yet when they go for a swim and step out of the lake, she has legs. It's not her having legs that is inconsistent, it's the fact that she can step out of the water at all when she has fins. I also wonder at them having the "luck of the Irish". It just seems like they would have no idea who or what the Irish are/were.

2. An expanse of blue water span shifting refelctions across it's surface. Reflections, not refelctions,

3. "hello," he began, safely enough. "What's your name?" hello should be capitalized.

4. "Yeah," he said, "first thing I did." I believe first should be capitalized also.

5. They awoke as the sun rose, and walked toward the edges f the forest to find breakfast. You left the 'o' off of 'f'.



Overall Impressions: A nice story that leaves the reading pondering all that exists in this story. Nicely done!



Sum1

** Image ID #1795794 Unavailable **
1016
1016
Review of The Reunion  Open in new Window.
Review by Sum1 Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.0)
Brian,
         Welcome to Writing.com, or WDC as we affectionately call it! I hope you meet many people here, and have as much fun as I have had in the last year.

         What a nice, but somewhat sad story you have of a 20 year reunion with your best friends from high school. To me it's sad because you were the only one who kept the commitment and showed up. (Frankly, I'd be calling or writing the others to find out why they didn't show.) This is nicely written, it flows well and kept me interested to the end. I do have a couple of suggestions for you.

1. Use 'WritingML' to indent your paragraphs. All you do is type the following (minus the space between the brackets and the word) { indent }. I had to put the space there, or you wouldn't have seen it, you would see the indent caused by the command.

2. I think some of your paragraphs would be better in front of others, just for flow purposes. (My opinion only, you will have to decide of course.) I guess an example would be better than explanation. Blue is original, green text is the moved paragraphs. I also used the "indent" command to indent the first line of each paragraph.

         At noon, on the Fourth of July, 1972, I stood in the farmyard, looking over a field of knee high corn, staring at Landy’s corner, about half a mile away. The scent of freshly mowed alfalfa was in the air; it was a beautiful day.

         In 1952, three high school friends and I formed a kinship. We were all farm boys raised near Cozad, Nebraska. We called ourselves the Oddballs, and at times did goofy things to live up to our name. We weren’t exactly daring, but one time we went into a local café and ordered, each of us wearing one glove. In a small town, someone is going to know you or your parents, so it took some nerve to do that with people wondering, what the…?

         We spent most of our leisure time (there wasn’t much leisure time for a farm kid back then) doing something together. We might have played basketball or Ping-Pong in the haymow of my parent’s barn, challenged each other to a foot race through the hills along spring creek, played two-on-two football in the stubble of an alfalfa field, gone to the county fair or a rodeo, or just hung out and talked about important stuff. Stuff like getting together for a reunion in twenty years.


         In 1952, Cozad was a small town with a population of 2910. The 100th Meridian ran through town, and the main North-South street was named Meridian Avenue. There was one stoplight in town, at the intersection of 8th Street and Meridian Avenue.

         The Oddballs needed a landmark, date, and time for the reunion. As high school kids, looking ahead to a date that would more than double our lifetime, we imagined that big changes would likely take place. We worried that if we picked the stoplight as a meeting place for the reunion there might be many other stoplights, and confusion could result. So, we decided to meet at Landy’s corner, on the Fourth of July, 1972, at twelve noon.

         Landy’s corner was the northwest corner of Landy’s farm. Landy was Rod’s brother-in-law. Rod had been staying on that farm so that he could finish high school in Cozad. His father had found work in another state, and his parents had moved there.

         I hadn’t lived in Cozad since 1958, the day of my marriage. Two days before my wedding, was the last assembly of the Oddballs, a bachelor party to remember. No guests, no entertainment, just drinks and fellowship, in Sam’s car, parked in a freshly harvested alfalfa field, reminiscing. Except for the drinks, it was typical Oddball craziness. We awoke at daylight, with hangovers, still in the car, still in the field. I vowed never to drink again.


         We were a diverse lot.

         Sam was a quiet, dependable person, of strong build, and destined to be a farmer like his father. He had boyish good looks, rosy cheeks, a quick smile, and got along with everyone. He was a crack shot with a rifle, and a champion blue-rock shooter.

         Hank was a handsome, athletic boy, tall and lanky, seemingly with no cares, and with no particular agenda. Spending time with Hank was great relaxation.

         Rod had rugged, good looks and seemed determined to do something important with his life. He was passionate about every undertaking, was a gifted writer, and was destined to seek his fortune elsewhere.

         I was a skinny kid, undersized for my age, and had a wisecrack ready for any occasion. I had no future plans, but luckily my father had some. Dad hadn’t finished college because his father became ill and he had to go back home and tend to the farming. He never broke away from the farm and felt trapped there. He was determined that I attend college and get an engineering degree. It happened.

         As the years went by, Sam and Hank married and remained in Cozad, on their family farms. Rod attended college, married and became a college professor and writer of note. I attended college and became an engineer. Rod and I both moved away from Nebraska.


         Then on to the rest of your story. This way, you keep the reader focused on Cozad in 1952, then move to you and your friends, and the planned reunion. Just a thought is all,,,,

         All in all though, nicely done!

Sum1


*Rainbowl*WDC POWER RAIDER*Rainbowr*

** Image ID #1795794 Unavailable **
1017
1017
Review of Dreams  Open in new Window.
Review by Sum1 Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with I.N.K.E.D.  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.0)
Witching Hour,
         I see by your profile that you are new to Writing.com, or WDC as we affectionately call it. Welcome!

         For such a short free verse poem, you tell a very poignant story here. How many times have each of us been in a situation much like the four your depict here? While it doesn't rhyme, that isn't an issue, it's free verse after all. It is nicely written with a flow that jumps a little, but still reads well. I did notice one thing you may want to consider in this.

1. dreams of a pink tutu wrapped in festively in a box,

I think you should delete the first 'in', in this sentence.

Nicely done though! Once again, welcome!

Sum1

** Image ID #1795794 Unavailable **
1018
1018
Review by Sum1 Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with I.N.K.E.D.  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
*Candleb*HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY FROM "Anniversary Reviews ~ Summer BreakOpen in new Window.*Candlev*


Aquaviann,
         I saw your suitcase on the Anniversary Review page, and thought I'd drop in for a visit. Happy 10th WDC Anniversary!

         Hmmm, never gave message boards a second thought. This is nice, I could almost see people posting, and the type of people they would be in real life. But I think you left out one category. People like me, who don't care about such things. *Smile* I have too much to do in real life to waste my time reading message boards. Oh wait, I don't have a life, I work two jobs, and have little free time, maybe that's why! Anyway, this was a different read for me, and really pleasant overall. Well done, nicely written!

Sum1

** Image ID #1795794 Unavailable **
1019
1019
Review by Sum1 Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with I.N.K.E.D.  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.5)
*Candleb*HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY FROM "Anniversary Reviews ~ Summer BreakOpen in new Window.*Candlev*


Dear Sue,
         I saw your suitcase on the Anniversary Review page, and thought I'd stop in for a visit. For the first time in a very long time, I'm thrilled I did, and am doubly thrilled at the chance to read this. Happy 5th WDC Anniversary!

         First, this is not a review, I'm not qualified to review this, nor can one do a decent review through eyes brimming with tears. My God, were you there? This is written as if you were involved in all this. I have a few comments, but they are not meant to be critiques, just helpful hints for something as wonderful as this. I remember the Beirut bombing, being a 20 year Navy Submarine veteran, stories like this are special to me. Thank you for the honor of allowing me to read this. My comments are below.



1. General comment: There are a few places where paragraphs are not double spaced. A few paragraphs are not indented like the others.

2. While he droned on in his nasal southern twang, Stacy sat at the one remaining seat at the conference table, Mike behind her by the wall, and mulled the possibilities of using local mortuaries. Semicolon after wall would be better.

3. Parked, Stacy grabbed a notebook, smoothed down her deep blue skirt over hips kept trim with running and tucked her sky blue blouse in tight. Parked is so short, add to it a little maybe.

4. “Good thought, Captain. We also need uniforms and medals for these men. You’ll be contacted by the Pentagon for a hand with details. “Captain,” he added, his gaze burning through her, “anything you need, you let me know.” Delete the quotation marks before Captain.

5. Grief seemed to sucked oxygen from the hangar. Delete the 'ed' in sucked.

Once again, thank you. My hat is off to you.
1020
1020
Review by Sum1 Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (3.0)
Fast2act,
         I saw your request for a review on the WDC Power Reviewer's List, and thought I'd oblige your request. This is a very good story of young love, aching love, and love that seems to finally come to fruition, although you did leave me hanging at the end. I don't know that they got the child finally, but that's fine, it's another part of this story. Your story is good, tells quite the tale, but does need a little exiting TLC so it can achieve better grades from future reviewers.


Title: To me, this title doesn't match the story, at least so far. The first paragraph matches it, a little. He's not a star athlete, that's pointed out in the first paragraph, but the rest of the story is about life! You may want to consider modifying the title, unless follow-on chapters will fit the title.


Description: Your description is a paraphrased sentence from the first paragraph also, and does not describe the story overall. A description is your chance to sell yourself, your 'product' if you will, so it's your chance to sell your story. Convince a potential reader that they really want to visit your port and read this!


Grammar: There are a few minor errors, I detail them below. But basically, you use finely instead of finally three or four times, and in at least one case, you did not capitalize the first word of a sentence, nor provide a space between it and the following one.



Characters: You could build your bride more. You tell us a little at first, but after that, we seem to lose her, other than having her around as part of the story. You never did tell us alot about you in the story either.



Rough spots?:

1. Your indentation of paragraphs was not consistent throughout the story. This is easily fixed with the 'indent' writingml command. Before the first word or a paragraph, simply type { indent } (Minus the spaces between the brackets and the word, if I'd left them out, all you would see is an indented portion of the sentence.)

2. I remember scanning through the crowd, a familiar face, just one person, someone that came to watch me play. I think you should have a semi-colon after crowd.

3. I liked how you repeated "My heart ached." every once in a while, it helps build things. However, it does appear a little too often at one point. One paragraph is just two lines, and it's before and after that paragraph. See if you can add a little to that paragraph so the two words aren't so close.

4. Summer break is just around the corner, as so many years before it seemed like an eternity until the last day of school. The rest of the story is written in the past. What I mean is that everything took place long ago. So, summer break was just around the corner,,,,

5. In that finite moment my attention swung, instead of checking the door to insure it was locked, I was drawn from my responsibilities to the annoyance I called my friend. In this sentence here, you make the reader think that something is going to happen since you forgot to lock the door. But you seemed to shrug this off, and later on you did lock the station up. This would have been a good place to have something out of the ordinary happen, maybe you didn't lock it up, and something is taken.

6. As a teenager, I thought my life was finely complete. As I mentioned above, it should be finally, not finely.

7. They think they know everything. one would think they'd already gone to the school of hard knocks. As you can see, 'one' should be capitalized.

8. It was a day like any other day; I woke, made my way to the kitchen to have a morning cup of coffee. This line starts awkwardly. Maybe this would work. One morning, on a day like any other; I woke and made my way to the kitchen to have a morning cup of coffee.

9. I won't detail them (but I will give a couple of examples), but there are several places where you capitalize a word in the middle of a sentence. Example: Summertime, finally School was out,,,,, or, “But What if we could?

10. Towards the end, you mention using a friends truck for the trip west in one paragraph, then again one or two paragraphs later. First, we had to load our friends truck with all our bags and packages. Next paragraph, Our friend Danny volunteered his truck and driving duties. That first sentence really belongs in this paragraph, after the second sentence.

11. We told him, you don’t have to take us, but with a quirky little grin he said “That is what friends do”. You need quotation marks around, you don't have to take us, and you should be capitalized.

12. The ending was a little bit of a letdown after the rest of the story, but I'm hoping you continue on in the next chapter.


Overall Impressions: A good story about a young couple, madly in love, desperately wanting a child.

You can share this image


Sum1

** Image ID #1795794 Unavailable **
1021
1021
Review by Sum1 Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.5)
*Candleb*HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY FROM "Anniversary Reviews ~ Summer BreakOpen in new Window.*Candlev*


Dear Rhyssa,
         I saw your suitcase on the Anniversary Review page, and thought I'd drop in for a visit. Happy 10th WDC Anniversary!

         It's not often that a story leaves me chuckling out loud, but this one did. I got a kick out of Peter joining the circus and having to 'work it out of his system'. The whole family sounded like quite the bunch, and that's the one thing I would have liked to see more in this story, more about your family. I figured you may have been under a word count limit, and thus shortened it, but it would be cool to read more about them, you, and of course, Peter. I have a little bit of feedback for you.



Title: Very apt for this story.


Description: I'm a firm believer that the description is what sells a story or poem to a potential reader. While yours is interesting, it could be a bit longer, and pull in more readers. (By the way, my descriptions aren't so good either, I'm good at seeing others, but can't for the life of me come up with good ones for my stuff). *Smile*


Grammar: Your grammar usage is very good.


Spelling: I noticed no errors.



Characters: You had quite a few in this short story, but we hardly got to know them. It's not a big deal, but you're dealing with circus people here! Think of how much you could have told about each of them. Then again, this story is about you and Peter, not them necessarily, so maybe it's not important. For me, I want to know more. *Smile*



Rough spots?:

1. Imagine, thirty-odd (and most of them are very odd) people—from Grandma who tells fortunes in the sideshow to several the kids, most of whom I’d never met before. I think you left the word 'of' out of this. It should be before 'the kids'.

2. You mention that you feel they hadn't disowned you because it had nothing to do with the circus. But in reading through this, I thought they loved you all along, but didn't stay in contact because of the different lives you, and they, live. You seemed almost ashamed of them, yet when you met them for the first time in years, they welcomed you back with open arms. So I had to ask myself, who had left and tried to forget the other? This is not a rough spot, just a general comment.



Overall Impressions: A very cute story of a family you left behind in order to pursue the dreams you had.

You can share this image


Sum1

** Image ID #1795794 Unavailable **
1022
1022
Review by Sum1 Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with I.N.K.E.D.  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (3.0)
Jon,
         This is an interesting idea you have here, but maybe you should look at it when you're not drunk. *Bigsmile* Seriously, this is interesting, but I think you stated your basic point about a 65 year old man's life two or three times. Each time, you said the same thing, but in a different format. Shall we say you went into this 'ad nauseum'? I see potential here, this could become a really nice piece. I don't call it a story, because it's more about writing than being a story. A story has a plot, a beginning, a middle, and an end. This has none of that. However, that doesn't mean it can't. My only comment to you, would be to delete the part about the graph, and what seems to be it's contents below it. It didn't copy and paste at all, so why even mention it?

         However, I did like the idea you presented here, breaking a story down into it's component pieces, much like you would a person's life. Nice idea!

Sum1

** Image ID #1795794 Unavailable **
1023
1023
Review of MY WISH 36 lines  Open in new Window.
Review by Sum1 Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with I.N.K.E.D.  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.5)
Yellow,
         Wow, Wow, Wow! Truly a very emotional piece. It flows so well that I didn't even look at rhymes or rhythm, I just read until I reached the end. A wonderful story told in poetic form, very nice! I hate to even think of looking at this for improvement, but one thing jumped out at me. In the last verse, nestle should be nestled. Thank you for the great read!

Jim
1024
1024
Review of The Phenomenon  Open in new Window.
Review by Sum1 Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with I.N.K.E.D.  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
*Candleb*HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY FROM "Anniversary Reviews ~ Summer BreakOpen in new Window.*Candlev*


Two Of Four,
         I saw your suitcase on the Anniversary Review page, and thought I'd stop in for a visit. Forgive me for being almost three weeks late with this, but Happy 9th WDC Anniversary!

         It's not often I get to read science fiction anymore, but it's always a pleasure. This is a really good story of a blossoming love, but what struck me as nice, was the difference in the characters. Ahna, all business, no time for pleasure. Not cold by any means, but still someone who is very difficult to get to know. Arthur, an artist, and seemingly a romantic. An odd couple to say the least, but I got the feeling they would get along well. Thank you for the most interesting and pleasurable read.


Sum1

** Image ID #1795794 Unavailable **
1025
1025
Review of Silken Desires  Open in new Window.
Review by Sum1 Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with I.N.K.E.D.  Open in new Window.
Rated: 18+ | (3.5)
*Candleb*HAPPY WDC ACCOUNT ANNIVERSARY FROM "Anniversary Reviews ~ Summer BreakOpen in new Window.*Candlev*


Lavender Sweet,
         I saw your suitcase on the Anniversary Review page, and thought I'd drop in for a visit. Happy 8th WDC Anniversary!

         You've written a very nice poem here, full of the anticipation in waiting for your lover's return. One can feel your love for him in every word. While this is a beautiful poem, there are a couple of things you might want to look at in this.

1. Your rhyme of surrounding and ending doesn't really work well, other than the 'ing' of each.

2. There are several places where the rhythm is off. What I mean is that some lines are longer than others syllable-wise. Here is your syllable count by line. 9/10/11/8/9/7/11/11/9/13. The jump from seven to eleven syllables is a big one, as is the eleven to nine to thirteen. It throws off the whole read.

3. You use "silken" to start the first two lines, and in a poem as short as this one, it's a detractor. You may want to consider changing one of them.

         Overall, a beautiful poem that needs just a little TLC for it to receive much better grades.


Sum1

** Image ID #1795794 Unavailable **
1,300 Reviews *Magnify*
Page of 52 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://writing.com/main/profile/reviews/jim-d/sort_by/r.review_creation_time DESC/page/41