\"Writing.Com
*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://writing.com/main/profile/reviews/chefneil
Review Requests: OFF
5 Public Reviews Given
5 Total Reviews Given
Review Style
I will read a story and get a feel for it, maybe take a few notes and then read it again and really look for high and low points, then I'll give the best criticism I can. My reviewing style and other preferences will evolve as my experience here, on writing.com grows. Does any one out there know how to flip that picture?
I'm good at...
I am not sure what I am good in reviewing some ones work. I will look for grammatical errors and plot inconsistencies.
Favorite Genres
I like almost everything.
Least Favorite Genres
I guess I don't like romance very much, at least the mushy stuff. This is a little ironic, see as how I am in the middle of witing an erotica novel.
Favorite Item Types
I am not sure what this means
Least Favorite Item Types
Dido
I will not review...
An opera. Everything else is pretty much open.
Public Reviews
1
1
Rated: 13+ | (3.5)
When some one asks to be reviewed, I think they really want an honest review, so please don't take offense to my nitpicking. I really think you have the beginning of an interesting story. So have a look at my in-text comments and use them or don't. However, just let them help you to a higher place in this fine story.

It is an interesting story, most intriguing. I think you are trying to build a dream like feel to it and you succeeded. I am lucky in that I have never been involved in an accident that has affected my cognitive abilities, any more then they already are at any rate (sic), so I can only guess what the effects are.

The whole thing with the finger ties in with one part of the story, but I am unclear how the whole story ties together. It seems like 2 desperate stories thrown together. This contributes to the dream like feel.

I think you are from England by the spelling you used, so I may be wrong in some of the grammar issues. Having said that, I think you should proof a little more, or ask someone to help. I run into the problem of knowing the story and inferring what I meant and find it helpful for some one else to give their input. They don't know the flow of the story and can help in building continuity and give a fresh look.

For the most part though, I found the story line interesting, though a little hard to follow. I wonder what it is that the protagonist has and why the mystery voice on the phone wants it. Could it be the finger. No. I think the finger removal is punishment. How does the gas and figure in the chair tie in?

Please continue on with the story and fill in the details more. What brought you to the opening scene and why?

In the paragraph where the bus accident occurs, does the obsession for the bag ad to the dreamlike quality?

As I walk into the room the smell of petrol flushes through my nostrils.(Too many syllables, maybe sinuses? too technical) Beside the door a petrol can lies on its side with its contents drooling (like this) into the carpet. A wooden desk sits in the centre of the room, with a high backed chair facing away from me. A writing lamp glows warmly onto(over) a stack of papers, a telephone, nothing out of the ordinary there. Smoke rises lazily from an ash tray on the desk. Mild panic to think of the petrol on the floor.(wording is difficult, impedes the flow) But still, I was brought here and the desire to know why is a powerful thing. A mirror on the wall reflects the light from the lamp. Something else is visible there. The fumes distort my vision. A few steps forward, I squint to see more. The chair faces the mirror. Something is on the chair, a dark shapeless matter.(matter? Seems like maybe a different word, figure, silhouette, shadow?) I reach forward to the lamp and swing the bulb upward. As light washes across the room I am hit from all sides at once. A(is this needed?) bile like nothing else rises in my throat(trite phrasing), an ice like dread. Primal fear. All encompassing.( like the repetition here, it ads to the drama) Then nothing. ( I understand the need to somehow define the nothingness of unconsciousness, but when i have been knocked out, I don't experience nothingness, it's more like experiencing becoming aware rather than losing awareness)(also think about tense)

#


The day before today(i wonder if "today" is needed?). The shrill tone of a phone message shook me out of a daydream. I was sat(sitting?) in my car, it was the last day of work. (you fired, the week end, why?)What was I thinking of(about?)? That(my college english teacher hated the word "that" and took points away when we used it. sometimes the simple word "IT" covers. But the word "that" hit the reading ear hard) (It)doesn’t seem important now. The message was terse and confusing. I stared at the words.(perhaps a comma here instead) “Where is it?” The phone number was displayed next to the message, I did not recognise it. Maybe it was a mistake. ("Maybe it was a wrong number")or ("maybe a mistake?") As I pulled away I wondered what it could mean. I drove up the service road. The car parks around the offices were mostly empty – people with places to go long since gone. I pulled up to the main road. At the junction a bag sat on the floor, the type of bag that you would take to the gym.("It was a gym bag") It was gold with a black logo. Just a bag, no person around,(Phrasing) the offices deserted. Maybe the security staff left it? My car indicator ticked. (not sure what this means, is it needed?)The display in the dashboard blinked like an annoying insect. I looked at the bag, wondering if I should pull over and look inside. It’s not my business, I thought. Maybe someone lost it. Maybe it’s something dangerous. Maybe I should look. Maybe not. I pulled away, still looking at the bag. The oncoming bus smashed through my car like it was not there. (maybe a paragraph break to show the shock of it?)

#


Shick. Shick. Shick. The noise plays across my consciousness. Shick, shick, shick. My eyes are closed. I can see through the morning light, out of my bedroom window. Shick, shick. Below is my neighbour, in his garden. Shick. His cat is chasing flies in the chilly air. Shick, shick. The hedge trimmer cuts through the hedgerow, its shiny steel blades clean and sharp. The hedge is uneven, imperfect. Shick. I’m drifting, falling through the window. Shick, shick. My hand in the hedgerow. Shick, shick. The noise is that of slicing, through bone, through flesh. I wake up. (I think this dream sequence is good, but maybe it could be more...smoothly done. It does jump around like a dream, yet dreams make a kind of sense when dreaming them.)

#


I awoke into whiteness. Bright lights stung my eyes. Looking straight up I saw rows of neon and clean painted ceilings. My body ached. I turned my head and winced with the pain lancing through my neck and spine. Beside me a person in white clothing looked away from me. A nurse or doctor I supposed. I am sure they saw me move but they did not look away from the chart they held. Beyond the half drawn curtains were more beds, some with blinking machines beside then. My segmented area had nothing but the aloof maybe doctor ( a comma, or the word "or" would help) maybe nurse. Eventually they looked toward(at) me. I could not read anything in their face (faces). I was very lucky. It was incredible but there were no injuries. Barely a scratch. Prescription pain killers for the whiplash. Home tonight. In the cabinet beside my bed a shrill ping caught my attention. I looked at my phone. The message read: “You have it. I want it.”. (Was the fnger missing here?)(tense again)

“How long was I out” I asked? “Not really sure what you mean?” was the reply. “Were you away or something? “Yes”, I despaired. I turned over in the bed. But I was not in the bed. Not in the hospital. I looked up. I was stood in a newsagent, in mid purchase. (need to work on this sentence a little) The shop keeper looked at me with a sort of confused indifference. I released the note which was taught(caught) between our hands. The shopkeeper said ”Right you are mate. Nice day for it” as he passed my change. The hospital was…I could not remember. I put out my hand to take the change and noticed the bandage wrapped tightly around my palm and fingers. My fingers. I stared at the man before me, not sure whether to trust what I was seeing. “Anything else was there?”(were you trying to sound like Yoda *Wink* ). I didn’t answer and turned on my heel to leave.

Outside. The clear skies left a chill in the air. My car was parked on the roadside. Across the way an iron railing called halt to the tarmac and welcomed in green playing fields. Beyond was every Sunday I have known. Children playing on some sort of swinging rope bound creature. A dog sent a flock of geese flying, running, screaming to the safety of the river. Was it Sunday? I got into my car and turned(on) the ignition. Beside me, on the worn beige passenger seat, was a golden bag with a black logo. (the same as the bag at the junction?)

I looked at the bag. The zip was done up tight. I tried the weight of it. Felt like nothing much. My head was still muggy from the accident. The past day felt unreal. I was in an accident, but there I was sat(sitting) in my car. The same car that had just yesterday been so easily smashed aside. I looked again at my hand. A small red patch had appeared on my palm. I unzipped the bag.

Inside the bag was a piece of paper with an address written in red ink and my severed finger.

#


I am awake. I am unable to see. Falling out of bed. Tripping over things which should not be there. The bag. A cold chill as I remember what (it) was. I feel my way across the room in the darkness. I pick it up. Only one thing left to do. I leave the room, the house. Into the yawning night.

I am wandering(...) lost. I follow a path decided by another. Inexorable. Towards that room. The room which I am afraid to enter. The room which contains an answer I dearly want.

#

the day after yesterday



I reeled in shock as I stared at the bag. I had no memory of the accident. I could not think clearly. The car engine hummed gently. I pulled off and drove home. Past the playing fields. Past rows of shops and people in their own worlds. Past the greys and greens. The landscape passed me by unseen and I could not understand what had happened nor how the bag had come to me. I arrived at the familiar( familiar what?). The overgrown hedges. The paint peeling from the windows and doors. Inside the house I heard that strange quiet that is only noticed when every sense is hyper aware. I walked upstairs and put the bag gently on the floor. I looked once more at my hand. The blood was dripping slowly onto the floor. Gingerly, I teased the tape away. Blood spewed forth and I looked at the stump where my finger once was. Was there something else there? Something tiny and moving. I passed out. (Need more here)

#


I am arrived. The door before me creaks and groans. The walls are a ruddy brown from the lamplight. The uneven surface of paintings barely seen. The smell of petrol. The desk and the mirror and the chair and me. I swing the lamp upward.

© Copyright 2014 P W Harman (UN: pwharman at Writing.Com). All rights reserved.
P W Harman has granted Writing.Com, its affiliates and syndicates non-exclusive rights to display this work.


When some one askes to be reviewed, I think they really want an honest review, so please don't take offense to my nitpicking. I really think you have the beginning of an interesting story. So have a look at my in-text comments and use them or don't. however just let them help you to a higher place in this fine story.

It is an interesting story. Most intriguing. I think you are trying to build a dream like feel to it and you succeeded. I am lucky in that I have never been involved in an accident that has affected my cognitive abilities, any more then they already are, so I can only guess what the effects are.

the whole thing with the finger ties in with one part of the story, but I am unclear on how the whole story ties together. it seems like 2 desperate stories thrown together. this contributes to the the dream like feel.

I think you are from England by the spelling you used, so I may be wrong in some of the grammar issues. Having siad that, I think you should proof a little more, or ask someone to help. I run into the problem of knowing the story and inferring what I meant and find it helpful for some one else to give their input. they don't know the flow of the story and can help in building continuity.

for the most part though, I found the story line interesting, though a little hard to follow. I wonder what it is that the protagonist has and why the mystery voice on the phone wants it. could it be the finger. No. I think the finger removal is punishment. how does the gas and figure in the chair tie in?

Please continue on with the story and fill in the details more come. What brought you to the opening scene?

In the paraggraph about the bus accident occurs, does the obsession for the bag ad to the dreamlike quality?

I look forward to seeing some fresh work here. Thanks for putting it out there.


olc
2
2
Review of Disappearing Act  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (4.0)
Hmm. Is this a retelling of a true story?

I liked the flow of the story. I could see what was going on throughout. The lack of details in th ehiding places worked well, my minds eye filled in the blanks. Nicely done.
I am not so sure of the use of "coop de maitre." I might have used Coop de Grace, But I have not seen your term before, so I am unclear as to its usage.
the way you transition from scene to scen was good, and I like the way you revealed the relationship between Thomas's parents.
I short the story was short, but complete. I enjoyed it.

On another matter, I have a blog on my journey as a single father and would like to talk with about posting this story. Let me know what you think.

olc
3
3
Review of Weekly Goals  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
Well, I have gotten a little more settled with writing.com

I did a review and sent it along.

I did a little research on crowd-funding and have made up where to go. Now all I have to do is define my goals there.
3 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 1 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://writing.com/main/profile/reviews/chefneil