\"Writing.Com
*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://writing.com/main/newsletters/action/archives/id/6778-Writing-in-Multiple-Genres.html
For Authors: January 21, 2015 Issue [#6778]

Newsletter Header
For Authors


 This week: Writing in Multiple Genres
  Edited by: Jeff Author IconMail Icon
                             More Newsletters By This Editor  Open in new Window.

Table of Contents

1. About this Newsletter
2. A Word from our Sponsor
3. Letter from the Editor
4. Editor's Picks
5. A Word from Writing.Com
6. Ask & Answer
7. Removal instructions

About This Newsletter

A header image for my official For Authors newsletters.


"The two most engaging powers of an author are to make
new things familiar, and to make familiar things new."

-- Samuel Johnson



Trivia of the Week: Even famous authors sometimes have to deal with concerns over publishing material with different genres or themes than their established success. Some famous authors who have used pen names to publish additional work include: Stephen King (as Richard Bachman), J.K. Rowling, (as Robert Galbraith), Lawrence Block (as Jill Emerson, Chip Harrison, Paul Kavanagh, and Sheldon Lord), Joyce Carol Oates (as Rosamond Smith), Nora Roberts (as J.D. Robb), Agatha Christie (as Mary Westmacott), C.S. Lewis (as Clive Hamilton and N.W. Clerk), and Michael Crichton (as John Lange, Jeffery Hudson, and Michael Douglas).


Word from our sponsor

ASIN: 1542722411
Amazon's Price: $ 12.99


Letter from the editor


WRITING IN MULTIPLE GENRES


A little over a week ago, I set up a poll called "Writing in Multiple Genres: Good or Bad?Open in new Window., designed to help answer one of the most enduring questions authors face. It seems that opinions on the matter can very greatly, from thinking it doesn't matter at all to the polar opposite view where it's incredibly detrimental to an author's chances of success. Here's what the voters on Writing.Com thought of the question:


      I read/write multiple genres; I think multiple genres has a likely negative effect.
      I read/write multiple genres; I think multiple genres has a likely positive effect.
      I read/write multiple genres; I think multiple genres has likely no effect.
      I read/write one primary genre; I think multiple genres has a likely negative effect.
      I read/write one primary genre; I think multiple genres has a likely positive effect.
      I read/write one primary genre; I think multiple genres has likely no effect.


That's a pretty overwhelming majority of respondents who feel that writing in multiple genres has a net positive result. It should be noted, though, that of the 30 respondents to the poll as of the writing of this article, 23 of the "multiple genres has a likely positive effect" votes were from self-admitted multi-genre readers and/or writers themselves. (It would have been 24 if I could have voted in my own poll! *Wink*) So is there any truth to the data, or is it just our wishful thinking? Here's what some actual people from the world of publishing have to say on the matter:


"It’s simply not feasible, especially in today’s competitive market, to try and be a jack of all trades. You can’t reinvent the wheel every time out. Choose the one thing you enjoy most and do it the best you can."
-- Rachelle Gardner (literary agent)


"When you are beginning as a writer, by all means, explore a few genres. Find out what seems the most fun to write, the best fit for your writing skills, what you are passionate about. Then focus. If you write a young adult contemporary and then the next book you pitch to us is for an adult, dark literary thriller, you are going to get an eyebrow raise."
-- Kristin Nelson (literary agent)


"The short answer is that it depends on which expectations you want to set and what your goals are. The longer answer is that Sean and I argued vehemently for writing across as many genres as you want under your own name, and that Dave disagreed with us."
-- Johnny, Sean, and Dave (hosts of The Self-Publishing Podcast)


"It’s important to identify your target audience for each genre. You need to define who they are, and learn about what they care about, what their challenges are, and how you can serve them. If you write for multiple genres, the audience for each will be very different—and you need to understand those differences."
-- Stephanie Chandler (author, bookstore owner)


"If you want to write different genres, use a pseudonym … stick to one name, one genre, because you’re building your brand, and brand building is a function of clarity – clearly communicating what you do, and what your product is."
-- Russell Blake (author)


"[My fans are] like, 'You know I’m not a big romance fan so just let me know when you’re going to write another paranormal or fantasy book and I’ll buy it.' And I was really kind of disappointed because I thought it was me they were following really like, 'it’s her voice.' So at first nobody followed me over so I kind of started from scratch with the romance but then when I started getting attraction in the romance and they started seeing my name and some good reviews I then had several of my YA readers go, 'You know what? I don’t normally read romance but I’m going to read it because it’s you and because I’m hearing good things.' So I did eventually get some crossover readers but there was definitely resistance there. And as far as the romance readers crossing over into the fantasy stuff, no it just doesn't happen."
-- Elle Casey (author)


"Will someone who loves your mysteries also enjoy your YA paranormal romance? Maybe, maybe not. But let’s assume you have a few faithful readers who will try anything you write, or who just happen to enjoy both of those genres. We’ll say, thanks to the success of your earlier works, you have 3,000 readers who bought and adored the novels in the first genre you tried. You’re hopping over to a new genre, and only 10% are willing to buy the new book. That doesn’t sound like many, but 300 book sales in the first few days of a release will get you onto some category Top 100 charts on Amazon, where your book has a chance of being seen by new readers, readers who adore that particular genre. They may not recognize your name, but if you have a good cover, blurb, and sample, they may give you a shot. And if they see that you’ve written another series that has garnered lots of positive reviews, that could be enough to sway them to try this new novel. From there… well, one never knows when a book given a head start like that can take off and sell well."
-- Lindsay Buroker (author)

If anything, this relatively small sample size and the poll data prove that there are vastly differing views on whether or not writing in multiple genres can help or hurt a writer's chances of success. Of the quotes above, though, consider that two of the most vehement detractors from the idea of writing in multiple genres were literary agents, whose job it is to essentially sell a writer to publishers. Could they be warning against multiple genres because it makes their job more difficult? Similarly, the most optimistic advocates for multiple genres were authors who write in multiple genres themselves (and have seen some success as the result).

Is it possible that the answer to this question is completely arbitrary?

I think it more likely that the answer to this question is not necessarily black and white, because it's a matter of circumstances and - at least in part - the fickle nature of an audience. The only absolute we know is that there are writers who have succeeded (and failed) with both a single genre (and multi-genre) approach. After researching this topic, I would offer the following insights about succeeding by writing in multiple genres:

*Bullet* Finding success by writing in multiple genres is a matter of commitment. Whether that's commitment to maintaining different personas for each pseudonym you use for each different genre, or commitment to cross-promoting and making sure your audience is aware of and willing to try your work in other arenas all published under the same name, it's a lot harder to keep multiple plates spinning instead of just one... but it can definitely be done if you concentrate and commit to keeping them all going at once.

*Bullet* The degree of difficulty increases the farther apart the genres are. If you write fantasy and YA science fiction, that's no so much of a stretch that you'll be shedding "crossover" readers in nearly as great numbers as if you write, say, YA science fiction and Regency romance. If your different genres include some of the same elements, it will be considerably smoother sailing than if you're trying to write in two genres that are so disparate you only have a handful of readers willing to explore both types of stories. J.K. Rowling went from children's fantasy to adult crime novels and decided to use a pseudonym to avoid confusion. Brandon Sanderson, on the other hand, uses his name name for all his work even though Steelheart is in the YA section and The Way of Kings is in the regular sci-fi/fantasy section.

*Bullet* There's a difference between tonal genres and content genres, and the latter is much harder to crossover. Content genres are those where the genre conventions are related to setting, story elements, or character archetypes: westerns, fantasy, science fiction, war, mystery, etc. These are genres whose readers come to expect to find certain familiar tropes in the books they read. Tonal genres, on the other hand, are ones where those specific tropes and conventions don't matter as much as the atmosphere or emotions the story creates: horror/thriller, romance, etc. It's easier to crossover and write multiple genres if you stay under the general umbrella of horror, for example, than it is to write in multiple genres where each one has a set of character, story, and setting conventions that don't overlap. Stephen King has made a remarkable career for himself being labeled as a horror writer, even though - depending on the story - his work contains could be classified as fantasy, science fiction, drama, paranomal, etc. And yet they reside in the same section of the bookstore because the overall tone and identity of his work is horror.

I originally asked myself this question because I'm someone who likes to write in multiple genres. Anyone who's rummaged around in my port can attest to the fact that I write a lot of different kinds of things. I suppose I wanted to try and find legitimacy to my theory hope that all the naysayers were just being negative or narrow-minded when they say you shouldn't write in multiple genres. I'm beginning to realize, though, that it's just as narrow-minded to foolishly think there isn't a cost associated with spreading yourself thin across multiple genres. There is a cost to be paid for writing in multiple genres, and based on what it seems like most moderates are saying, is the cost of your time and energy to maintain a presence in each genre you've chosen to pursue. For some people, the freedom to write in multiple genres is worth that added cost. For others, it might be too high a price to pay when they can be content writing in one primary genre.

I'm still not sure what kind of writer I am, but at least this project has helped open my eyes to the realities of what's ahead, whichever genre(s) I eventually want to define myself with.

Until next time,

Jeff Author IconMail Icon
Logo for Senior Moderators - small

If you're interested in checking out my work:
"Blogocentric FormulationsOpen in new Window.
"New & Noteworthy ThingsOpen in new Window.
Community Activities




Editor's Picks


I encourage you to check out the following items:


 
1.1 My Kind of Story Open in new Window. [13+]
What is genre and why it's important
by Eric Wharton Author Icon

EXCERPT: If you don't pick a genre, it will eventually pick you. This can work, but it's not ideal. It's important that you have a good feel for the conventions of genre before you begin. Some writers just write what moves them, and fit it into a genre later. Others are more mercenary and look for genres that will sell the best and then write their story. Most authors probably fall somewhere in between. They give thought to genre, but don't let it dictate too much what they want their story to say. No one can say for certain which is best for you, but at least try to give genre more than just a passing glance.



 Invalid Item Open in new Window. []

by A Guest Visitor

EXCERPT: Raise your pen if you want to gain maximum exposure for your posted items on W.com. The single most important thing (which will produce significant results) is to accurately record data when completing, (or editing) your 'Create an Item' page.



 A Defense of Fantasy Open in new Window. [E]
Proving that the fantasy genre is indeed just as important as others.
by Shadowsong Author Icon

EXCERPT: Fantasy fiction is a genre that is controversial to many. Some love it, others hate it. Some consider it an important aspect of literature; others think it but a frivolous and immature genre, a phase to grow out of. And yet, it is the genre that has been around the longest, with its roots dating back to 2000 B.C. So if fantasy fiction is merely a phase to grow out of, why hasn’t the human race grown out of it? What about fantasy makes it so appealing that it has stayed popular for thousands of years?



 Science Fiction Genre Open in new Window. [18+]
What is science fiction?
by Cosmic Voice Author Icon

EXCERPT: The range of science fiction is far wider than the name implies. It is not necessary to write about technological developments; the effect of those developments may provide more imaginative scope. The explosion in knowledge, in new technological developments, in consumer goods, and in social change has been overwhelming since World War II. Science fiction is one attempt to understand the knowledge and the social change brought about by this technological boom.



 Citizen Journalism--An Emerging Genre Open in new Window. [E]
I registered as reporter PatRice and discovered journalism is a specific style of writing.
by a Sunflower in Texas Author Icon

EXCERPT: A couple of months ago, I ran across a site in an Internet search for "writing". The site was referred to as one for "citizen journalists" to submit articles, and get them published at the site. Since most of my published work has been poetry entered in a contest, I decided to venture off my beaten path, and take a stab at writing interesting news.


 
Submit an item for consideration in this newsletter!
https://www.Writing.Com/go/nl_form

Word from Writing.Com

Have an opinion on what you've read here today? Then send the Editor feedback! Find an item that you think would be perfect for showcasing here? Submit it for consideration in the newsletter!
         https://www.Writing.Com/go/nl_form

Don't forget to support our sponsor!

ASIN: 0997970618
Amazon's Price: $ 14.99


Ask & Answer



Feedback from my last newsletter about holiday stories:


Tornado Dodger Author Icon writes: "Excellent topic my friend. I couldn't agree more. Keep up the great work in 2015!"

Thanks, Brooke! I'll do my best!



monty31802 writes: "A fine News Letter Jeff Merry Christmas."

Merry Christmas to you too, Monty!


*Bullet* *Bullet* *Bullet* Don't Be Shy! Write Into This Newsletter! *Bullet* *Bullet* *Bullet*

This form allows you to submit an item on Writing.Com and feedback, comments or questions to the Writing.Com Newsletter Editors. In some cases, due to the volume of submissions we receive, please understand that all feedback and submissions may not be responded to or listed in a newsletter. Thank you, in advance, for any feedback you can provide!
Writing.Com Item ID To Highlight (Optional):

Send a comment or question to the editor!
Limited to 2,500 characters.
Word from our sponsor
ASIN: B01MQP5740
Amazon's Price: $ 4.99

Removal Instructions

To stop receiving this newsletter, click here for your newsletter subscription list. Simply uncheck the box next to any newsletter(s) you wish to cancel and then click to "Submit Changes". You can edit your subscriptions at any time.


Printed from https://writing.com/main/newsletters/action/archives/id/6778-Writing-in-Multiple-Genres.html