\"Writing.Com
*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
BY ONLINE AUTHORS
Printed from https://writing.com/main/my_feedback/action/view/id/4795762
Review #4795762
Viewing a review of:
 Dead Man's Regret Open in new Window. [E]
A different perspective on Desiree's Baby by Kate Choplin
by VENACAVA Author Icon
Credit this reviewer
#4795762
Review of Dead Man's Regret  Open in new Window.
Review by Prier Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (3.5)
Access:  Public | Hide Review (?)
Dead Man's Regret

Review By Prier


Summary
         "Dead Man's Regret" by Venacava is a poignant and tragic short story told from the perspective of Armand La'bri, a man consumed by guilt and regret over his actions. He reflects on his pride and cruelty, which led to the death of his wife and the loss of his child. In a final act of remorse, he writes a letter to his late wife's parents, apologizing for his deeds and expressing his intention to free the slaves he once mistreated. Overwhelmed by his guilt and unable to face the consequences of his actions, he takes his own life, believing he is destined for hell. The story ends with his death, paralleling the fate he inflicted on his wife.


Grammar and Spelling Errors
         1. Ellipses Usage: The ellipses ("...") are overused and inconsistent in spacing, which disrupts the flow of the narrative.
         2. Tense Shifts: There are occasional shifts between past and present tense, such as "I plan to set the slaves free" (present) versus "I had burned every remnant" (past).
         3. Sentence Structure: Some sentences are fragmented or awkwardly constructed, such as "It was my origin that had been touched with the 'brand of slavery.'"
         4. Punctuation: Missing or misplaced punctuation, such as the lack of a period after "Opening the window, I found myself at the top of my house."
         5. Word Choice: Phrases like "I will blind thy eyes and curse thy scornful mouth" feel out of place and inconsistent with the rest of the narrative tone.
         6. Spelling: No major spelling errors were detected.

Constructive Criticism
          The story has a strong emotional core and explores themes of guilt, pride, and redemption effectively. However, the narrative is hindered by inconsistent tone, awkward phrasing, and underdeveloped context. The protagonist's motivations and backstory are hinted at but not fully fleshed out, leaving the reader with unanswered questions about his relationship with his wife and the events leading to her death. The use of archaic language in certain parts ("thy eyes," "scornful mouth") feels inconsistent with the otherwise modern tone of the story.
         Additionally, the pacing is rushed, particularly in the climax, which diminishes the emotional impact of the protagonist's final act.


Suggestions for Improvement (Ordered by Importance)
         1. Develop the Backstory: Provide more context about the protagonist's relationship with his wife, the circumstances of her death, and his internal struggle. This will help readers connect with the characters and understand the weight of his regret.
         2. Clarify Tone and Language: Decide on a consistent tone—whether modern or archaic—and revise the language accordingly to maintain coherence.
         3. Address Pacing Issues: Slow down the narrative, especially in the climax, to allow the emotional weight of the protagonist's actions to resonate with the reader.
         4. Revise Sentence Structure: Simplify and clarify sentences to improve readability and flow. Avoid overusing ellipses and fragmented sentences.
         5. Expand on Themes: Explore the themes of pride, guilt, and redemption more deeply. For example, delve into the protagonist's decision to free the slaves and how this ties into his personal redemption arc.
         6. Polish Grammar and Punctuation: Address the tense shifts, punctuation errors, and awkward phrasing to enhance the overall professionalism of the piece.


Overall Quality
         "Dead Man's Regret" is a deeply emotional and thought-provoking story with a compelling premise. While there are areas that need refinement, the raw emotion and themes of guilt and redemption shine through, showcasing the potential for a powerful narrative. With some additional development and polishing, this story could leave a lasting impact on its readers. Keep writing and refining—your voice has the ability to evoke profound emotions!

-Prier


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
   *NoteR* You have not yet responded to this review. Ignore
Printed from https://writing.com/main/my_feedback/action/view/id/4795762