\"Writing.Com
*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
BY ONLINE AUTHORS
Printed from https://writing.com/main/profile/reviews/rick12221
Review Requests: ON
913 Public Reviews Given
931 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... -1- 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 ... Next
1
1
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
This Thanksgiving prayer has a heartfelt and reflective tone, offering a sincere expression of gratitude and remembrance. Here's my review:

Strengths:
Warmth and Gratitude: The poem beautifully conveys a sense of community and thankfulness. It captures the essence of Thanksgiving—appreciating blessings, loved ones, and shared moments.
Faithful and Reflective: The references to the Lord and prayer add a deeply spiritual and reverent touch, making it a fitting piece for a Thanksgiving gathering centered around faith.
Acknowledgment of Loss: Remembering those lost in the events of September (presumably referring to September 11) adds depth and a poignant layer of compassion and shared grief. This touch honors the past while focusing on healing and love.
Areas for Improvement:
Flow and Structure: While the prayer reads smoothly overall, some lines feel slightly disjointed. For instance, "On that day of September" could benefit from a more specific or evocative reference to clarify the event being commemorated.
Ending Rhymes: The final prayer section could be integrated more seamlessly with the rest of the piece. While it's a lovely sentiment, it feels a bit detached, almost like an add-on. A smoother transition could make the conclusion feel more cohesive.
Consistency in Style: The shift between the main prayer and the concluding couplet disrupts the rhythm slightly. You might consider either reworking the ending to match the overall tone or incorporating the final couplet earlier as a refrain.
Suggestions:
Add more descriptive imagery to enhance the emotional impact, like details of the feast, the warmth of loved ones, or the light of faith.
Refine some rhymes to maintain a consistent rhythm. For example, the line “Thanks to everyone / Who has brightened our lives” could flow better with a tweak, such as “Thanks to all who bring light to our days.”
If the prayer is meant to be read aloud, ensure a smooth cadence by revisiting line breaks and syllable counts.
Overall, it's a touching and meaningful prayer that captures the spirit of Thanksgiving. Polishing the structure and flow would make it even more impactful.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
2
2
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
This piece weaves an atmosphere so rich and vivid that you can almost feel the warmth of the café, smell the mingling scents of espresso and rain-damp wool, and hear the faint strains of a violin in the Parisian streets. The descriptions are lush without becoming overwhelming, striking a balance that immerses the reader in a world of intellectual intrigue and artistic pretension.

The characters stand out as fully realized personalities, each adding a unique flavor to the narrative. Julian's magnetic charm and existential musings, Solène's sharp wit and fierce creativity, and Étienne's sly irreverence form a compelling trio that makes the dialogue crackle with life. Their dynamic feels authentic, as though you're eavesdropping on an intimate conversation among old friends. The interplay of their views on art—seduction, theft, obsession, and reflection—provides the narrative with philosophical depth without dragging it down.

The settings—whether the café, the rain-slicked streets, or the museum—act as more than just backdrops. They are characters in their own right, shaping the tone and mirroring the group's complex relationships and ideals. The café, for instance, feels alive, a microcosm of Parisian culture where debates about art and existence unfold like a theater performance.

If there is a critique, it’s that the dialogue occasionally teeters on the edge of self-awareness, which might alienate readers looking for a more grounded story. However, this style suits the heightened, almost mythic quality of the narrative and its characters.

The ending—where their laughter and camaraderie spill into the streets—beautifully ties the story together. It leaves a lingering sense of transience, capturing the fleeting magic of a moment that, like art, cannot be fully captured or understood. This story excels in creating a vivid, atmospheric world where beauty, intellect, and vulnerability collide.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
3
3
Review of Until  Open in new Window.
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
This poem has a beautifully evocative and meditative tone, capturing a longing for connection with the sea. The imagery is vivid and immerses the reader in a sensory experience. Here's a closer review:

Strengths:

Imagery: The poem paints stunning visuals, like "grains of sand slip like time" and "bright corals shimmer, painting the ocean floor with light." These lines create a tactile and luminous quality.
Emotional Depth: The repetition of "Until" builds a sense of yearning and incompleteness that resonates throughout the piece.
Rhythm and Flow: The lines flow smoothly, and the structure lends a natural rhythm that mirrors the ebb and flow of waves.
Suggestions:

Overlapping Concepts: Some ideas, like the connection to the soul and the sea's embrace, appear in both stanzas. While this reinforces the theme, slight variation could add depth. For instance, exploring the sea’s connection to the speaker’s past or future might broaden the emotional scope.
Final Lines: The last line of each stanza emphasizes resolution ("I will not be in peace" / "I will not be whole"). While powerful, rephrasing one of them might avoid redundancy and allow for a more distinct conclusion to each stanza.
Imagery Expansion: The mention of "waves carving a name" is compelling—perhaps expanding on what this name signifies could add personal meaning to the poem.
Overall Impression: The poem is heartfelt and atmospheric, striking a balance between nature’s beauty and human introspection. With minor refinements, it could resonate even more deeply with readers. It feels like a work that invites the reader to reflect on their own connection to the natural world and the search for inner peace.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
4
4
Review of All too well  Open in new Window.
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
This piece beautifully captures the rawness of loss and the bittersweet ache of nostalgia. The imagery is vivid, painting a scene of quiet grief that feels both personal and universal. Lines like "Your perfume that is forever etched in those walls" and "Everything now- is matted to dust" are particularly evocative, showing how memories linger even as the physical world decays.

The emotional core of the poem is strong, especially in the way it portrays the relationship between the narrator and their sister. The dynamic between them is heartfelt, full of depth, and relatable, from the petty arguments to the shared dreams of building an "empire." This makes the loss all the more poignant.

The repetition of "I miss..." towards the end builds momentum, underscoring the depth of the narrator's longing. It effectively mirrors the way grief often loops, circling back to the same thoughts and feelings.

There are a few places where tightening the phrasing could enhance the rhythm and flow. For example, "Hot tears from the warmth of my heart spring forth from my eyes" could be more concise while retaining its emotional impact. Additionally, some lines feel slightly over-explained, such as "Offer me tea, knowing all too well how I hate it," which could benefit from a subtler approach.

Overall, this poem is a touching and heartfelt tribute to the bond between siblings, brimming with love, loss, and an aching sense of absence. With a little refinement, it could become even more powerful.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
5
5
Review of Carnival  Open in new Window.
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)

Your poem captures the whimsical and lively essence of a carnival while adhering to the Lento form quite well. Here's my review:

Strengths:
Creative Use of Rhymes: The poem maintains the required rhyme structure of the Lento. The rhyming of the first words across the lines in each stanza (Half-Ralph-Wrath-Laugh in the first quatrain, Titanic-Ecstatic-Erratic-Fanatic in the second) adds a playful and engaging touch.
Imagery and Mood: The imagery of the "Big Top" and "Talent Pond carnival" creates a vivid scene of excitement and fun. It feels inviting, like an open door to a world of wonder.
Flow and Rhythm: Although the Lento form does not require a fixed syllable count, your poem has a good rhythm that makes it easy to read and enjoy.
Suggestions for Improvement:
Clarity and Continuity: The mention of Ralph, Roni, and Ken in the first quatrain is intriguing but could use more context. Who are they? Perhaps a little more detail would make their presence feel more integrated into the carnival scene.
Enhanced Imagery: While "Titanic events" and "Ecstatic are adults and kids" are lively descriptions, you could expand on these moments to paint an even more vivid picture. For example, what kind of "Titanic events" are happening? A little more specificity might make these lines more impactful.
Consistency in Tone: The light-hearted tone is enjoyable, but the mention of "Wrath" in the first quatrain feels slightly out of place in the otherwise jubilant atmosphere. Perhaps a different word could be chosen to keep the mood consistent.
Overall, your poem is a delightful piece that follows the Lento form well and evokes the joy of a carnival. A few tweaks to add more context and refine the imagery would make it even more engaging. Keep up the great work!

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
6
6
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
This story has a strong premise and engaging personal voice, but there are a few areas where it could be polished to make it even better. Here are some suggestions:

Strengths:
Relatable Voice: The narrator’s candid tone and self-awareness make the character likable and easy to relate to, even if they’re flawed. This draws readers in and makes them want to root for the protagonist.
Clear Progression: The journey from frustration to finding a solution is logical and has a natural flow.
Engaging Ending: The "forty years later, still in business" line gives a sense of accomplishment and wraps up the story nicely.
Suggestions for Improvement:
Grammar and Sentence Flow:

The sentence "I’m wasn’t being smart" has a typo; "I’m" should be "I." This kind of slip can take readers out of the story.
Tighten some of the longer sentences. For example: "I’m actually quite intelligent, I just don’t take orders well, and I’m always telling people how much better what they are doing would go if they just tweaked it a bit" could be simplified: "I’m intelligent, but I don’t take orders well. I keep telling people their work would improve if they made a few tweaks."
Clarity of Events:

The transition from walking on the beach to starting a new business feels a little rushed. Expanding on the narrator’s thought process would strengthen the connection between these events.
The first client’s story could use more detail. Why did the client go bankrupt? Was it really the protagonist’s advice, or did the client misinterpret or overdo it? A clearer explanation would add depth and make the lesson learned more impactful.
Character Development:

While the narrator’s flaws are evident, showing moments of growth throughout the story would make the character arc more compelling. For example, what specific lessons did they learn from the failed first client?
Dialogue or Specific Interactions:

Adding a brief conversation with the first client could make their dynamic more vivid. For instance, show the client enthusiastically taking advice or panicking when things go wrong.
Ending Expansion:

The ending could touch more on what sustained the business for forty years. A hint of what the narrator improved over time would add a satisfying sense of closure.
Final Thoughts:
This piece has a lot of potential as a slice-of-life reflection. With some fine-tuning of pacing, grammar, and depth, it could become an even more engaging and insightful story.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
7
7
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
This poem has a mystical and complex tone, with layers of abstract imagery that suggest themes of morality, innocence, and mythological struggles. However, its intricate phrasing and dense symbolism can make it somewhat challenging to interpret. Here’s a breakdown of its strengths and potential areas for refinement:

Strengths:
Evocative Imagery: Lines like "Driven towards the heavens" and "A tightly woven cherub" create vivid, almost celestial visuals that transport the reader into a mythical and otherworldly setting.
Exploration of Morality: The juxtaposition of innocence and "a truly mischievous credit" hints at a critique of moral ambiguity, adding depth and thought-provoking substance.
Rhythmic Quality: The poem flows well with its short, punctuated lines, creating a sense of urgency and emotional weight.
Philosophical Undertones: Phrases like "The wisdom goes beyond religious sentiments" suggest a deeper reflection on human nature and belief systems.
Areas for Improvement:
Clarity of Theme: While the poem's abstract nature is intriguing, it risks being too obscure for readers to connect with its central message. More concrete connections between innocence, morality, and the mythical host could enhance its impact.
Consistency in Tone: Some lines, such as "barren holes could signify a toasty, available riddance," feel slightly out of place compared to the more solemn tone of the rest of the poem. This could be rephrased to maintain the overall atmosphere.
Character and Purpose: The poem introduces intriguing elements like the "mythical host" and "holy spectacle" but doesn't fully develop their roles or significance. Expanding on these ideas could enrich the narrative and give the poem a stronger sense of direction.
Abstract vs. Accessible: While abstraction can be powerful, anchoring some ideas in tangible experiences or emotions might make the poem more relatable.
Suggestions:
Consider revising the "barren holes" metaphor to better align with the rest of the poem's tone and themes.
Expand on the "mythical host" or the "tightly woven cherub" to give readers a clearer sense of their symbolism or role.
If the poem critiques secularism or explores youthful struggles, clarifying these points could make its philosophical reflections resonate more strongly.
Overall, the poem is rich with potential and offers a fascinating exploration of profound ideas. A bit more focus and refinement could transform it into something even more compelling.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
8
8
Review of How To Meditate  Open in new Window.
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
Your poem, Find Your Quiet Space, captures the essence of mindfulness and meditation beautifully. The imagery is soothing, and the structure flows naturally, mirroring the process of relaxation. Here are some points of praise and suggestions for improvement:

Strengths:
Tone and Imagery: The tone is calming and reflective, perfectly suited for the subject of mental and physical rejuvenation. Phrases like "Breathe slowly in, inhaling positivity" and "Travel through ethereal dimensions" evoke a sense of tranquility and boundless exploration.
Structure: The gradual progression from physical relaxation to mental wandering and then back to reality is well-organized, guiding the reader through a meditative journey.
Ending: The closing lines, "Set up and smile, for you have traveled, / Where plane, nor boat can go," leave the reader with a sense of wonder and accomplishment.
Suggestions:
Consistency in Imagery: While the poem effectively conveys relaxation, the imagery could be deepened in places. For instance, "Entertain mystical imaginings" could be expanded with more vivid descriptions of these imaginings to make them feel tangible.
Word Choices: Consider rephrasing "Set up and smile" to "Sit up and smile," as it flows more naturally with the context of the poem.
Pacing: Lines like "Push away any negative thoughts, / And continue on your journey" feel slightly abrupt compared to the rest of the poem's smooth rhythm. You could elaborate on the "journey" to maintain the gentle pacing.
Overall, this is a lovely piece that captures the restorative power of finding one's quiet space. With a bit of refinement, it could become even more evocative. Keep writing!

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
9
9
Review of Flower  Open in new Window.
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
This poem is a heartfelt exploration of a serene moment in nature and the emotions it evokes. Here's my take on it:

Strengths:
Imagery: The poem uses vivid imagery to transport the reader into the forest. Phrases like “blossoming meadow” and “shines brighter than the sun” paint a clear, almost magical picture of the setting.
Emotion: The emotional connection to the flower is palpable. Lines like “A tear fell, right onto its floret” convey a deep, almost overwhelming reaction, making the reader feel the intensity of the moment.
Flow: The poem flows naturally, with a rhythm that mirrors the gentle yet sudden experience of discovery and awe.
Suggestions for Improvement:
Structure: While the free-verse style works, the poem could benefit from slight restructuring to emphasize its emotional peaks. Breaking it into stanzas could create pauses that reflect the speaker's experience.
Ambiguity in Expression: Phrases like “my whole being felt still” and “I dared not feel” could be refined for clarity. For instance, elaborating on why the speaker "dared not feel" might deepen the emotional impact.
Conclusion: The ending is poignant but abrupt. Expanding on how the flower’s light “never leaves my eyes” could give more weight to its lasting significance.
Overall, this poem beautifully captures a fleeting yet transformative moment, balancing the quiet majesty of nature with the speaker’s inner turmoil. With a few adjustments, it could become even more impactful!

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
10
10
Review of A Dangerous Gift  Open in new Window.
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
This story has a compelling premise and great emotional weight. The generational curse of the Fire Bearers, coupled with Phil's inner conflict, creates a strong narrative hook. However, a few areas could benefit from refinement to make it even stronger:

Emotional Depth and Dialogue:
The characters' emotions come across well, but some dialogue feels stilted. For example, Phil's transition from shock to experimentation with his powers could delve deeper into his thought process. Instead of just stating his fascination, show his internal struggle more vividly. What specific memories or desires drive his curiosity to master the fire?

Worldbuilding:
The lore of the Fire Bearers is intriguing, but it could use more fleshing out. What exactly makes the power uncontrollable? Why was it revered in the past but deemed worthless now? Adding snippets from the ancestor's journal, perhaps contrasting past glory with modern struggles, would enrich the story's background.

Pacing:
The story shifts quickly from Phil's discovery to his experiments, then to the climactic fire rescue. While the action is engaging, the progression feels rushed at times. Allow more space for Phil to grapple with his father's warnings and his growing desire to use his power.

Character Development:
Phil's arc is compelling but could be deepened by exploring his relationship with his father further. How does he view his father's warnings? Does he feel resentment, love, or pity? Similarly, Lucien's struggle with guilt and fear could be expanded to make his warnings more impactful.

Climactic Scene:
The rescue scene is thrilling and showcases Phil's heroism, but it could benefit from more sensory details. What does the heat feel like against his skin? How does the smoke impair his vision? These elements would heighten the tension and immerse readers further.

Ending Hook:
The story ends mid-rescue, leaving a sense of incompleteness. Even if you’re planning to continue, a small resolution—such as Phil emerging from the house with Tony's family or a reflective moment—would give the reader a more satisfying conclusion to this chapter.

Overall, this story has a solid foundation with strong emotional stakes and an intriguing premise. Refining the pacing, adding depth to the characters, and enriching the lore will elevate it further. Keep going—this has the potential to be a memorable tale of power, responsibility, and redemption.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
11
11
Review of The Party  Open in new Window.
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
This short story, The Party, effectively captures a slice of life moment with a relatable mix of joy and unexpected emotions. The narrative focuses on a simple family gathering that turns into an emotionally charged memory, especially for Jacky. It delivers a clear and bittersweet lesson while offering a heartwarming yet realistic depiction of human nature. Here's what stood out:

Strengths:
Relatable Theme: The story portrays a common childhood experience—being the center of attention at a party. Many readers can empathize with Jacky's overwhelmed reaction, making the narrative engaging and personal.

Atmosphere: The description of the gathering is lively and vivid. The warm day, colorful tablecloths, and children playing create a cheerful and picturesque setting that contrasts nicely with Jacky's eventual meltdown.

Characterization: Dot's multitasking as a mother and hostess, Nancy's helpfulness, and Jacky's typical behavior are well-drawn, adding depth to the family dynamic. Even in a short piece, these small details breathe life into the characters.

Twist Ending: The story's ending, with Jacky's aversion to surprises solidified for life, adds humor and poignancy. It ties the story together and gives readers something to reflect on about personality traits shaped by early experiences.

Suggestions for Improvement:
Build-Up to Jacky's Reaction: While her outburst is impactful, a hint of her discomfort earlier—perhaps through her body language or hesitation—could make her reaction feel more grounded and less sudden.

Transition Between Events: The jump from "after the food" to the surprise reveal feels a bit rushed. Adding a few sentences to build anticipation or show the family's effort in setting up the table would enhance the pacing.

Expand the Emotional Impact: Jacky's reaction is a pivotal moment, but exploring her inner thoughts or giving a brief exchange with Dot afterward could deepen the emotional resonance of the story.

Polish the Narration: Lines like "it was time for the party!" could use more descriptive flair to heighten excitement. Similarly, the concluding sentence might be stronger with a reflective tone, emphasizing how this moment shaped Jacky's character.

Overall Impression:
The Party is a charming and insightful snapshot of family life with a memorable takeaway. By enhancing the emotional depth and pacing, the story could leave an even more lasting impression on readers. It's a great foundation for exploring how small moments leave a significant mark on our personalities.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
12
12
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (5.0)
Your poem has a surreal and abstract quality that invites deep interpretation. It balances vivid imagery with profound ideas, giving it an almost meditative tone. Here’s a breakdown of what stands out and some thoughts for refinement:

Strengths:
Imagery: The opening lines evoke a blend of tension and beauty. Phrases like “fearful pails and seething gasps” and “paramour of awestruck beaming” create a striking contrast that captures attention.
Tone: The philosophical depth, especially when reflecting on themes of love, forgiveness, and divinity, is thought-provoking.
Structure: The poem flows with an almost stream-of-consciousness rhythm, which works well for its introspective nature. The shorter, standalone lines like “By unsubstantiated offers” and “Whose sewing involves a quilt” create pauses that emphasize their meaning.
Suggestions for Improvement:
Clarity vs. Obscurity: While abstract poetry thrives on ambiguity, some lines—like “Infinity’s classification yielded / By unsubstantiated offers”—feel overly opaque. Providing a clearer anchor for the reader might strengthen the emotional impact.
Word Choices: Phrases like “penultimate harmony” and “vociferous roar” can feel slightly grandiose, potentially distancing the reader. Simplifying or grounding some expressions could heighten their relatability.
Consistency in Metaphors: The quilt metaphor in “Whose sewing involves a quilt” is intriguing but feels disconnected from the rest of the imagery. Expanding on or tying it more clearly to the broader themes (e.g., love, forgiveness, or divinity) would enhance its significance.
Ending Strength: The closing lines about an “Almighty’s kingly, / Vociferous roar” are powerful but abrupt. Consider elaborating on the divine connection to tie the poem together more cohesively.
Overall Impression:
Your poem is rich with emotion and artistic flair, but tightening some of the more elusive elements could make it even more impactful. The balance of beauty and introspection shines through, and with a bit more clarity, your voice will resonate even stronger.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
13
13
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)

It seems like you've provided a structured list of headers and data points. Here's a review of the format and content:

Strengths:
Clear Headers: The repeated "HEADER CLM X" format suggests you have a structured framework. This could work well for organizing information if fleshed out further.
Numerical Data Points: Using "Data X" gives an impression of sequential entries or items related to each header. This could be useful for lists, tabular data, or hierarchical structures.
Suggestions for Improvement:
Content Under Headers: It’s unclear how the data aligns with the headers. Adding specific details or descriptions under each header will improve clarity and usability.
Example: If "HEADER CLM 1" represents a category, list all relevant data points beneath it.
Avoid Repetition: "Data 4" appears twice, which might confuse readers. Ensure unique entries or clarify if repetition is intentional.
Label Refinement: The generic "HEADER" and "Data" labels lack context. Descriptive names or keywords can better convey meaning.
Example: Replace "HEADER CLM 1" with "Category: Sales Data."
Hierarchical Formatting: Consider using a nested structure if certain data points belong to specific headers. For instance:
HEADER CLM 1
Data 1
Data 2
HEADER CLM 2
Data 4
Contextual Explanation: Providing a brief introduction or conclusion about the purpose of these headers and data points can make it more comprehensible.
Overall Assessment:
While the structure is foundational, adding context and refining organization would significantly enhance clarity and utility.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
14
14
Review of Emily's Steer  Open in new Window.
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
This story tugs at the heartstrings with its emotional depth and blend of humor, sorrow, and introspection. It offers a compelling mix of slice-of-life simplicity and a touch of the fantastical, creating a memorable narrative that is both heartfelt and thought-provoking.

The bond between Emily and Moses is beautifully portrayed. From the tender moments of nursing the calf back to health to the bittersweet final days, the relationship feels authentic and relatable. The description of Moses believing he’s one of the barn cats adds charm and lightness, providing a delicate balance to the heavier themes of loss and sacrifice.

The appearance of the magical milk can and the cow genie is an unexpected twist that adds a layer of whimsy. It’s an effective narrative device to explore the protagonist's internal conflict about loss, love, and the consequences of wishing away pain. The humor in the cow's sudden speech and the protagonist's reaction—"What the heck?!?!"—grounds the scene, making it relatable and engaging rather than jarring.

The resolution is especially poignant. Instead of succumbing to the temptation of easy fixes, the protagonist's decision to forgo the wishes underscores a deeper message: life’s pain and joy are intertwined, and removing one can diminish the value of the other. This mature, reflective conclusion elevates the story from being just a whimsical tale to a meaningful exploration of human experience.

Some areas for improvement:

The narrative could benefit from slightly tighter pacing, especially during the wish-pondering section. While thoughtful, it becomes a bit repetitive and risks losing momentum.
Consider providing more resolution about Emily’s reaction to Moses leaving. Closing the emotional loop would give the story greater completeness.
Overall, this is a touching, creative piece that captures the complexity of love, loss, and the lessons that come with them.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
15
15
Review of A Trip Inspired  Open in new Window.
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
This reflection is a heartfelt journey through personal memories, travel, and appreciation for art. The author does an excellent job weaving their love for travel with a deep connection to the painting of the Frisco Fishing Pier. The narrative evokes a sense of nostalgia and respect for nature’s power, while also capturing the resilience and determination of people.

The story behind the painting enriches the personal significance it holds. The description of the painting itself, with its vivid imagery of morning sun, storm clouds, and the worn pier, creates a visual for the reader that mirrors the emotions tied to the memory. The author’s appreciation for the art’s ability to capture a fleeting moment of beauty and history is beautifully expressed.

The historical context provided by the shop owner adds depth to the story. It transitions the painting from a simple souvenir to a piece of living history, connecting it to the experiences of anglers and visitors over decades. The detail about the pier's removal and the preservation efforts offers a bittersweet closure, emphasizing the impermanence of human creations against the enduring forces of nature.

The conclusion ties the piece together, reflecting on the painting as both a keepsake and a reminder of life’s fleeting moments. It inspires the reader to cherish their travels and mementos while celebrating life’s adventures.

If anything could enhance this piece, it might be a bit more about the family dynamics during the trip, as it would add warmth and a broader sense of connection. However, as it stands, this review is a touching testament to the power of art and memory.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
16
16
Review of Be Descriptive  Open in new Window.
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
Share


You said:
review - Welcome back! Today's topic is going to be imagery.

It is one of my absolute favorite things to include in my writing, and it also adds to the "BEEF" (If you know you know)

I enjoy swapping out common words for uncommon words, like just now, as I write this, I first typed, "I like," but then i decided to say, "I enjoy. If I had said I like, you probably would have already left.

When you write, think about ways to add more adjectives and words to small sentences. But ALWAYS remember the importance of short sentences.

All in all, I like to write, and write I do.
ChatGPT said:
ChatGPT
Your piece on imagery has a fun, conversational tone, which makes it approachable and easy to follow. The way you weave in your personality, like referencing "BEEF" (though it’s a little cryptic), adds a unique flair that engages readers. Still, there’s room to tighten the focus and polish the message.

Strengths:

Relatability: The conversational tone makes readers feel like you’re speaking directly to them, which is great for connection.
Practical Advice: Encouraging the use of uncommon words and more adjectives is a solid tip for enhancing imagery.
Passion: Your enthusiasm for writing shines, and that energy can be contagious.
Suggestions for Improvement:

Clarify "BEEF": If "BEEF" is a concept or acronym you’re referencing, briefly explain it. Readers might feel left out if they don’t "know."
Consistency in Tone: You start with a polished introduction but slip into a casual style (“like just now, as I write this”), which might feel unrefined to some. Balancing casual and formal elements could make your advice more impactful.
Structure: While the tips are helpful, the piece jumps between topics (imagery, adjectives, short sentences) without much transition. Consider organizing your points more clearly:
Define imagery.
Explain how word choice enhances it.
Highlight the balance of sentence length.
Closing: The ending feels rushed. You could wrap up with a final thought or encouragement about how imagery transforms writing.
Revised Example of Your Style:
"Imagery is one of my favorite writing tools because it pulls readers into the world you’re creating. Swapping common words for more interesting ones is a simple way to do this. For instance, instead of saying 'I like,' I’ll say 'I enjoy'—it feels richer, right? But don’t forget, even with beautiful adjectives, short sentences carry power too. Writing is a balance, and mastering imagery is one way to make your work unforgettable."

Your enthusiasm for writing is evident, and with a few tweaks, this could inspire others to embrace imagery like you do!


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
17
17
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
This poem beautifully captures the complexity of internal struggles and the strength it takes to navigate them. The imagery is vivid, balancing the turmoil of unseen battles with a powerful sense of hope and resilience. The consistent rhythm and rhyme scheme lend it a soothing, almost meditative quality, making the emotions feel authentic and relatable.

The contrast between the external calm and internal storm is striking, especially in lines like “The smile’s a mask, the laughter a shield, / Hiding the wounds that never quite healed.” These lines resonate deeply, as many people can relate to putting on a brave face despite inner pain.

The shift in tone from despair to hope is particularly impactful. Lines such as “Yet in the shadow, a flicker of light, / A whisper of hope in the darkest night” serve as a turning point, providing comfort and inspiration. The use of natural imagery, like the rising sun and stormy rain, effectively conveys the emotional journey from struggle to healing.

The closing stanza is empowering, reminding the reader of their inherent strength and capacity for renewal: “You are the dawn after the endless night.” It leaves the reader with a sense of optimism and solidarity, emphasizing that no one is truly alone in their fight.

Overall, this poem is heartfelt and poignant, offering solace and encouragement to anyone facing difficulties. It’s a gentle reminder that while the journey may be tough, hope and courage can light the way forward.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
18
18
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
This poem has a nostalgic and reflective tone, weaving themes of teamwork, challenges, and the bittersweet journey of striving for success. Here's what stands out and could use improvement:

Strengths:
Theme of Resilience: The poem captures the ups and downs of being part of a team, especially the trials faced in pursuit of greatness. Lines like "The new ups and downs seem truly prescriptive" convey the learning process involved in overcoming hardships.
Imagery of Teamwork: Phrases like "The most treasured bliss, and the games played together" evoke memories of camaraderie, while "Daily and nightly, a proponent, a must" underscores the dedication required to succeed.
Rhyming Structure: The rhyme is consistent and gives the piece a rhythmic flow, making it pleasant to read.
Suggestions for Improvement:
Clarity in Narrative: While the poem explores a journey, the storyline feels somewhat fragmented. For example, the transition between "after the enemies" and "champions forever" could be clearer—are these moments of triumph, failure, or both? Tightening these ideas could enhance readability.
Word Choice: Some phrases, such as "free flowing plans" and "the critiques and the shame are advanced," feel abstract. More vivid or specific imagery might make the emotions and actions more relatable.
Pacing: The shift from "fall apart" to "a new start" feels abrupt. Expanding on the aftermath of failure or the hope for redemption would add depth.
Resolution: The ending feels unresolved with "Wishing that winning was simple and just." It leaves the reader yearning for closure. Perhaps adding a final thought about the journey being its own reward could tie it together.
Overall Impression:
The poem has potential to be a poignant reflection on the struggles and joys of teamwork. A bit more narrative clarity and evocative imagery could elevate it further. It’s relatable and has the beginnings of something memorable.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
19
19
Review of LONLEY bucket  Open in new Window.
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)

This piece presents an interesting metaphor about the mind as a broken bucket and explores whether it is worthwhile to try to fill it, despite its imperfections. The symbolism is clear: the bucket represents the mind, and water represents emotional or psychological fulfillment. The premise invites reflection, but the execution could benefit from refinement.

Strengths:
Creative Metaphor: Comparing the mind to a broken bucket is a fresh way to discuss human struggles, particularly feelings of emptiness and futility.
Thought-Provoking Question: The narrative challenges readers to think deeply about the purpose of effort, even when the results seem incomplete or impossible.
Encouraging Perspective: Opinion A suggests that trying to fulfill the bucket, despite its flaws, has value. This is a hopeful and motivating message.
Areas for Improvement:
Grammar and Clarity: The writing has several grammatical errors, which make it harder to follow. For example, "Putting the water in the bucket is meaningless" could be revised to "Pouring water into the bucket feels meaningless."
Incomplete Argument: Opinion A starts a discussion about the purpose of the bucket and the mind but ends abruptly. For example, the sentence, "For instance, if there are no communication and conversation," is left unfinished. Expanding on this idea would make the argument stronger and more persuasive.
Flow and Structure: The transition between the metaphor and the opinion could be smoother. Adding more context or examples to Opinion A would help readers better connect with the idea.
Suggestions:
Revise for Clarity: Clean up grammar and phrasing to make the piece easier to understand. For instance, rephrasing "Although we try to fulfill it. Is it true?" to "Even though we try to fill it, can we ever truly succeed?" improves flow.
Expand on the Argument: Flesh out Opinion A with more examples or counterpoints to create a balanced discussion. For instance, you could explore what "filling the bucket" might look like in real-life scenarios—friendship, personal growth, or creative pursuits.
Conclude Strongly: End with a summary or a call to action. For example, "Even if our minds are like broken buckets, trying to fill them brings purpose and growth. Isn’t that reason enough to keep pouring in the water?"
Overall, this draft has the potential to be a meaningful piece about perseverance and purpose. With a bit more depth and polish, it could leave a lasting impression.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
20
20
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)

This piece does a great job capturing tension and the subtle nuances of a close friendship under stress. Here are some highlights and suggestions:

Strengths
Character Dynamics: The relationship between Liz and Francis feels authentic and layered. The lack of explosive fights but the palpable tension is an interesting dynamic, making their disagreements stand out more.
Natural Dialogue: The dialogue flows well and feels realistic. Liz and Francis’s back-and-forth carries emotional weight, and you can sense the history and closeness between them.
Subtle Foreshadowing: The narrative builds curiosity as to what Liz is hiding. It keeps the reader invested, eager to learn what’s causing the tension.
Satisfying Payoff: The surprise birthday party is a great twist, resolving the conflict in a heartfelt way. It ties together the earlier tension, showing Liz’s struggle was all for a good reason.
Areas for Improvement
Pacing: The middle section, where they argue in the car, is a bit drawn out. You might want to condense some of the dialogue to maintain the reader’s interest. Fewer lines could still convey the tension without feeling repetitive.
Liz’s Inner Conflict: While Liz’s anxiety about the situation comes through, adding more internal reflection could enhance the emotional depth. Maybe a few more hints about her guilt for lying could make her struggle more tangible.
Setting Descriptions: Descriptions of the environment are minimal, especially during the car scene. A few sensory details (like the hum of the engine or the streetlights flashing by) could enrich the atmosphere.
Ending: The resolution is sweet, but Francis’s reaction could be fleshed out more. Maybe add a moment where he realizes how much Liz went through to make the party happen, emphasizing their bond.
Final Thoughts
Overall, the story is engaging and captures a genuine, relatable conflict. The surprise ending is touching, making the buildup worth it. If you tighten the pacing and add a bit more depth to Liz’s internal struggle, it will shine even more brightly. Great work!

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
21
21
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
This poem captures the essence of a serene moment in nature. The imagery evokes a peaceful lakeside scene filled with the sounds and sights of birds, bees, and flowing water. The theme centers around connecting deeply with the natural world and experiencing a sense of harmony and spiritual upliftment.

The use of visual details, like “water lake where various birds are decent” and “different type of trees,” helps set a vivid atmosphere. The idea of “bees flying to get ride of fruit and flower” and “fishes swimming for own aspect and gain” adds a sense of nature’s purpose and interconnectedness. The line “My inner state of mind opened to imagine heavenly” beautifully captures the feeling of being spiritually transported by nature’s splendor.

However, there are a few areas where the writing could be refined. Some phrases could be adjusted for better flow and clarity. For instance, “To get ride of fruit and flower where was flying some bees” could be simplified for readability. Similarly, “Swimming the fishes for own aspect and gain” feels a bit awkward and might benefit from rephrasing to make the imagery more vivid.

Overall, the poem has a dream-like quality and an appreciation for the natural world that shines through. With some editing to improve the grammar and rhythm, the piece could be even more impactful. It captures a genuine sense of awe and wonder, which is its greatest strength.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
22
22
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
Your story has a captivating and heartfelt core, full of rich imagery and vivid emotions. Here are some key strengths and areas for improvement:

Strengths:
Vivid Descriptions: Your descriptions of Yorkshire and the past are rich and immersive. The way you painted the scenery—from the cobblestone streets to the bustling abbey—invites readers to step into your world. Phrases like “the air thick with the scent of freshly baked bread” and “the gas lamps casting flickering shadows” bring the scenes to life.
Emotional Connections: The bond between Grammar and her descendants is beautifully portrayed. The intergenerational interactions are touching and relatable, especially when the children engage with their ancestors, creating a sense of warmth.
Engaging Narrative: The story flows smoothly, and the idea of a time machine adds an exciting, almost magical element. The children’s curiosity and the adults’ disbelief create a compelling contrast.
Suggestions for Improvement:
Clarity and Pacing: Some sections could benefit from more concise writing to maintain a steady pace. For instance, the scene of the family stepping out of the time machine and meeting their ancestors is powerful but could be streamlined to heighten the impact.
Dialogue Tags and Repetition: Dialogue occasionally feels repetitive, with descriptions that echo the surrounding narrative. Simplifying dialogue tags and focusing on the action can make conversations feel more natural.
Character Differentiation: While the large family is introduced effectively, some characters blend into the background. Giving each family member a unique trait or moment would make them more memorable. For instance, detailing how Tracy’s love for history influences her reactions could deepen her role.
Grammar and Spelling: A few minor errors, such as missing spaces after punctuation or extra commas, interrupt the flow. For example, “Grammar stepped off the train” should perhaps have a comma before “the cool British air.” Proofreading for these will make the text more polished.
Overall Impression:
The story beautifully captures the nostalgia and magic of reuniting with ancestors. It carries an enchanting quality, blending history and family bonds in a way that resonates emotionally. With some tightening and refining, it could be a deeply moving tale about heritage and the ties that connect us across time. Keep going; this concept has so much potential!

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
23
23
Review of Insomnia  Open in new Window.
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
This short story sets up a humorous and relatable situation using the classic theme of an unwanted house guest. The opening line, "It’s one am. Time for the night noises to begin," instantly creates a feeling of anticipation, hinting at something sinister or unsettling. The following onomatopoeic "Bang!" draws readers into the moment, and we quickly learn that the cause of the disturbance isn’t an intruder or ghost, but a possum. The humor in the situation feels genuine, especially as the narrator’s desperation is revealed.

Your dialogue is effective in characterizing both the narrator and Frank, with Frank’s nonchalant response of “I’ll sort him out tomorrow” painting a picture of someone who is accustomed to nightly disturbances or who simply isn’t bothered enough to act. The narrator’s thoughts about resorting to poisoning the possum are funny and relatable, reflecting just how sleep deprivation can lead us to extreme (though not serious) fantasies.

The ending, "Listen! Our possum’s gone. At least until morning when he comes back," ties things up with a light-hearted conclusion. It emphasizes that this is an ongoing battle, and there’s a sense of resignation mixed with relief.

Overall, your story captures a relatable experience with humor and vivid detail. To strengthen it further, you could add more sensory descriptions of the possum's sounds or the narrator's frustration to immerse readers even more.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
24
24
Review of Throne Room  Open in new Window.
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
The throne room you’ve described paints a vivid image and has a strong sense of grandeur mixed with intrigue. The focal point of the huge red velvet chair at the room’s center captures a classic, almost medieval royal aesthetic. The cascading red carpet that flows toward the double doors adds an elegant touch that immediately sets a majestic tone.

The wall decor of past kings’ marble statues gives a sense of legacy and history, while the royal crest symbolizes authority and power. This imagery evokes respect and hints at a legacy steeped in tradition. The description of the heavy curtain concealing an opening meant for dragon dignitaries introduces a unique twist, suggesting that the throne room isn’t just for human or humanoid audiences but has adapted to accommodate mythical beings. It makes the setting feel alive and ripe for fantasy storytelling.

The iron door in the back right corner, left ajar, adds a layer of mystery to the otherwise grand and ceremonial space. The sense of an invisible pull leading there builds suspense, making you wonder what secrets the room holds. This detail pulls readers in, suggesting a deeper narrative or potential conflict lying in wait.

Overall, the setting is described in a way that immerses readers immediately in a fantasy world. There’s a good balance of opulence and mystery, setting up an atmosphere that could lead to thrilling development.

WriterRick (WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group)


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
25
25
Review of Old Winds  Open in new Window.
Review by WriterRick Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: E | (5.0)
"Old Winds" weaves nature and memory into a flowing, introspective journey that taps into themes of time, continuity, and transformation. The poem’s imagery of “old winds,” “old waters,” and “old leaves” effectively personifies elements of nature as ancient witnesses, guiding the reader through a landscape where past and present are intertwined. The tone feels both reflective and slightly haunting, as if these natural forces carry secrets from times long gone.

Each stanza builds on this theme with vivid language: “Old winds blow through canyons carved by time,” for example, creates a sense of history and permanence. These winds become messengers, “bringing hints of worlds beyond distant horizon” and subtly reminding us that change is ongoing, yet somehow eternal. The poem’s structure—moving from wind to water, sound, and earth—gives a cyclical feel, mirroring natural processes and life’s unending flow.

The final lines bring a powerful sense of connection to these “mutterings of the ancestors,” portraying the winds as conduits for both renewal and a call toward the future. By ending on the image of the wind “ever dancing to the heartbeat of my soul,” the poem beautifully emphasizes a personal link to the natural world’s timeless rhythm. This piece succeeds in evoking a sense of reverence and wonder, inviting readers to reflect on how the “old winds” in their own lives might be gently guiding them forward.


*Gold* My review has been submitted for consideration in "Good Deeds Get CASH!" Open in new Window..
679 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 28 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://writing.com/main/profile/reviews/rick12221