First of all, welcome to WDC! I saw in your feedback request that you were cringing at asking for a critique being so new. Don't worry about that, that's what we're all here for!
This is a very powerful piece, and I can't imagine growing up like this. It feels autobiographical, and the reader gets sucked in right from the first sentence, feeling the angst right away. Growing up in the type of environment you describe has to be awful. May I ask the time frame? This feels like it's set a while ago, when tensions between the German and Jewish people were still raging. Not having grown up in that type of environment (I'm from a small farm town in New York State, originally) I'm not sure as to the state of the tension between the two groups these days. I would hope it's subsided a bit.
I wouldn't change much at all. Maybe the line about your father would sound better if it read "He would tell me he was not raising a wimp or a punching bag." I feel like that flows a bit better. Also, you mention that you knew who you could beat a couple of times, when it really only needs to be stated once as it's a memorable part of the narrative. Maybe phrase it a little differently in the fourth paragraph so it doesn't feel like you're repeating yourself - "Just as I knew who I could successfully take on, I also knew those that I didn't stand a chance against" or something like that just so you're not using "I knew who I could beat" twice.
But, all in all, this is a great piece of writing. I enjoyed it and at the same time it made me uncomfortable, which I hope was your intention. I'm curious as to what the "very special book" was. I think you should elaborate on that a bit, not even necessarily saying what it was but more of what it was about.
I really enjoyed this. It was a great description of a man who really wanted something, something so simple, but was a major undertaking for him to get it. The reader finds himself feeling what Stephan is feeling - how what was once a simple thing has now turned into something difficult - and how frustrated he is with this. This was a man that used his hands for a living all of his life, and now he had great difficulty grasping a simple glass of water.
The description reminds me of a scene in one of my favorite films, The Fisher King, where Robin Williams' told the story where the king wanted a drink of water and the fool gave it to him, and the cup turned out to be the Holy grail. "How could you find that which my brightest and bravest could not?" "I don't know. All I knew is that you were thirsty."
I loved reading through this! The two of you listen to a lot of the same music as I do. I'm especially a fan of Bob Dylan and Leonard Cohen, and I see that Herman's Hermits were mentioned. I had the opportunity to see Peter Noone perform live in Atlantic City a few years back and the guy is still incredible. He has the energy of a 25-year-old.
Music is something which is very important in my life, and I love meeting and seeing other people who care about it as much as I do. I'm making this a favorite so I can follow your conversation.
You say you're trying to restructure this, but I honestly don't see the need. I think it's good exactly as it is. The only one thing I'd change is the last line (and this is just my personal opinion, take it for what it is) to "You are" instead of "You were" because I get the feeling from this poem that that the subject of it is still someone very important to the speaker.
I like this a lot. It's very personal, I feel. In poetry, the meter doesn't have to be structured throughout. It doesn't have to be perfect. This flows very well, and I enjoyed reading it.
Printed from https://writing.com/main/profile/reviews/nomad42
All Writing.Com images are copyrighted and may not be copied / modified in any way. All other brand names & trademarks are owned by their respective companies.
Generated in 0.10 seconds at 7:07pm on Nov 24, 2024 via server WEBX2.
View Portfolio
Visit Notebook
Send Gift Points
Awards
Badges
Send Email
Community Newsfeed
General Discussion
Sponsored Items
Book of Trinkets
Static Items
Books
Groups
Interactive Stories
Audio
Campfire Creatives
Community Notes
Crossword Puzzles
Documents
Folders
Images
In & Outs
Madlibs
Photo Albums
Polls
Product Reviews
Quizzes
Survey Forms
Web Pages
Word Searches
