\"Writing.Com
*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://writing.com/main/profile/reviews/dryad13
Review Requests: OFF
5 Public Reviews Given
9 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
1
1
Review by Dryad Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
For a few moments, I was living this fallen artist's life. You have a gift for painting a picture of words and then making it come alive in the reader's mind. Not many people are able to do that in prose, as authors have a tendency to get 'telly.' That is, they spend so much time making sure that their vision is translated to the readers they hope to reach that they end up preaching, almost, to their projected audience because they want to make sure that what they are saying/thinking/feeling isn't missed. There were many things that really stood out for me, really gripped my attention and pulled me into your piece and held me there. Some of the lines that really struck me:
How can I leave him if I can’t bring myself to get out of bed? I think we have all asked ourselves that question, male or female, of any relationship we haven't been happy in. We grow complacent, it's just easier, we're afraid to date, we don't know what to do next, we have a million myriad reasons not to change what we're used to whether we are happy or not-as though our mere existance makes us unworthy of the happiness we so long for.
I walked seven blocks to the hospital, and came home with long white bandages up and down my arms. He still didn’t notice. But at least I got the ring back.I think this shows the character's true desperation more than any other portion of this piece. No matter that she tried to get away and didn't succeed; no matter that she hasn't been bothering to perform regular hygiene tasks; no matter that she stares in despair at the wall, the uncleanliness of the house, the dishes; this woman is clinging to that circle that has professed to bind this man to this woman for life-till death do they part. And she has slowly come to the realization that it is her death she is facing. It may not be a death of body, but her soul is slowly perishing for want of something more. The circle of life, the neverending circle of love, the circle of regeneration have all been promised to her by this man who does not even notice that she has damaged herself to retrieve the symbol of what she thought was their union. He has lied to her in the worst way: without ever saying a word, without causing her to continue to feel the joy, the lust, the love he made her feel in the beginning of their lives together.

I had a professor once tell me that if the first line and the last line of a book or story or even poem don't make you want to read everything in between then you shouldn't bother to read it. [I don't listen to that, but I do think it applies here.] Your first line: He gets out of bed with a grunt and thumps from the bedroom to the bathroom. And your last line: This is my morning, evening, and night: staring at the wall until he comes back home and bores me to sleep with his heavy, pointless breathing. Tell me you wouldn't want to read everything in between?

The only concern I had with this whole piece was one portion towards the beginning. I felt that there was a superfluous word in the following paragraph: The sudsy water sloshes over a bit onto the counter before I can get to turning it off, so I eat my breakfast with one hand and grab a sponge to wipe the counter with in the other. The sponge comes up grayer; it must have been a while since the counter’s been cleaned, I guess. I sigh, swallow the last bite of bagel, and turn back to the dishes.

You'll notice that I turned the bold off at 'in' and 'grayer. I think 'in' should be removed for ease of reading, and that 'grayer' could be transferred out for a word that gives a stronger sense of dirt. I had to read over that a couple of times to understand that you meant the counter was dirty.

Very good writing!
~Dryad
EnduReviewII
2
2
Review of Dreams Gone By  Open in new Window.
Review by Dryad Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Very well written!! I found myself wondering and wondering what was wrong with your lead character, although I had suspected. A truly good story draws the reader in, making the reader want to read on and find out what the climax is going to be and how it's all going to work out. You did a very good job of this!

Although your intent for this was likely only a short story, I do think you could have given the reader a little more with respect to your characters. While you should show the reader who the characters are, rather than spelling it out [she had blonde hair, blue eyes, and was only 5'2", as an example] there were quite a few opportunities to expand the dialogue between the two so that we would have known how old the boy was; how he reacted to the information would have given the reader a lot of information about how he thought; etc.

I did greatly enjoy this story; it seemed as though it was written straight from the heart. I find that those stories written in such an emotional vein tend to work a little better than those that are penned 'just because.'

Good work and keep writing!!
~Dryad
Endureview II
3
3
Review by Dryad Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (4.0)
This poem has a bittersweet feeling about it. The word 'prised' though does not work. I cannot find it in the dictionary, and I suspect that you mean 'pried' which is, essentially, to tear something away from something else.

The third stanza doesn't flow as well as the rest of them. I think it's because of the comma after 'the sadness I feel for a while.' It seems to read better if you remove that comma so that it does not force the reader to pause. The line 'things once more will please' seems to be lacking something, as well, because it is insinuated that the narrator means things will please him again. However, I can't come up with something that will rhyme and still mean the same thing. [One of the reasons that the poetry I write so rarely rhymes!]

You're very brave to write a poem of such strong emotions that rhymes, I think. Rhyming poetry seems to have a rhythm and cadence that is almost sing-song in nature, and it's difficult to still show the feeling you have shown without making a poem seem 'corny.' I think you have succeeded in this respect. I sense the strength of your convictions without feeling that the poem is childish or like a nursery rhyme. Well done!
3 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 1 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://writing.com/main/profile/reviews/dryad13