Hello Natbutteflyblue . This review comes courtesy of "Invalid Item" . Thank you for sharing your fantasy story Airianna, Chapter 1. I hope my comments are helpful.
First Impression: The story begins in the middle of an attack by unknown mercenaries on a palace. The main protagonist, Faith, braves the over-run castle, avoiding the invaders to find the princess, Airianna. Discovering the princess cornered by a mercenary, Faith dispatches him and then leads the princess through the castle searching for an escape route.
Punctuation/Spelling/Grammar: In the bold title you have Arianna, which is just missing the i in Airianna
There are some technical issues with the first line of the chapter :- Faiths breaths came in rapid gasps,... Apostrophes are used to show ownership or missing letters. You could also change breaths to breathing or breath to make this read better. E.g.
Faith's breath came in rapid gasps, or Faith's breathing came in rapid gasps.
This room had once been Airiannas nursery,.. Same here. It is Airianna's nursery You used an apostrophe on Lady Amaranth's apartments, but later, not on Airiannas life or Airiannas gaze, which need one.
...a trapdoor in the ceiling where delivery's were made... Here it is the opposite. The deliveries are plural and don't need an apostrophe.
Overall Impression: I liked that you started the story in the middle of the attack. I felt Faith's fear immediately, but the first line was a little awkward. There is tension right from the beginning as Faith experiences a range of emotions. Her anger at seeing her friend in danger was a good way to break her trepidation and show some of her character's strength. The trickery she employed to avoid the guards was good too, showing her quick-wittedness.
What I didn't understand was, why is Faith there? She talks about getting to the princess and that they were friends as children. She is also friends with Tah'lon, the palace guard. I would have liked to know why Faith is so concerned with the princess. Is she a noble or a servant, or just a friend staying at the castle? On the other hand, I don't mind that the mercenaries are unidentified, because in the midst of the invasion, there would be confusion. Their motives and employers could be explained in later chapters.
Overall, I think you have a chosen a great way to start the story, with action. Faith comes across as a much stronger character than Airianna. As a consequence, I am more interested in Faith and relate to her, much more than the princess. I am tempted to read on to find out what caused the attack. Who are the mercenaries? Where will they go?
Suggestions: The first line of a story is so important and I think you need to reassess this one. I'm not so sure about her pulse pounded against the side of her throat. I suspect you are trying to get away from the cliches such as a lump in her throat or thumping in her chest, but maybe more like her throbbing heart throttling her throat. or something like that.E.g.
Faith's breath came in rapid gasps, her throbbing heart rising up to throttle her throat.
The wound gushed open, drowning the princess in a wave of hot blood. I think drowning could be replaced by showered or similar. E.g.
The open wound gushed, showering the princess with a spray of hot blood.
Violent sounds pieced the air... The sounds aren't themselves violent, so I would suggest this could be rearranged slightly to Sounds of violence pierced the air.
When Faith freezes and closes her eyes, she then describes how close the man comes to the corner. I think it needs to be described aurally, as in she heard the man come close or his footsteps approach. These are all just suggestions. See what you think yourself and what others give you.
Adoration: I think this makes for a promising beginning. I particularly liked some of the imagery and descriptions. Overall, it was the tension of being caught or spotted that really kept me reading and interested.
Felicitation: It was a joy and pleasure to read and review your first chapter of Airianna. With some revisions and tweaking, I would be happy to reread and re-review this chapter, Natbutteflyblue, and I will read the next chapter. Write On!
Michael
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** |