\"Writing.Com
*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://writing.com/main/profile/reviews/dc1291
Review Requests: OFF
181 Public Reviews Given
297 Total Reviews Given
Public Reviews
Previous ... -1- 2 3 ... Next
1
1
Review by David Gere Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)

Magigenesis – Chapter 2 – Mikita

The hierarchy of the different ranks of magicians show that they can be very powerful in creating a complex magical world where every class obeys the rules and laws of that class. In that way, this book seems to be very unique and one that doesn’t exist anywhere else except the author’s head where it came from

It’s a little hard to follow so many introductions of different types of magicians so fast though.


The plot in this chapter gets right into it. This chapter seems to start the real story better than Chapter 1. It has more action, from the viewpoint of the protagonist, rather description –which is something different in that is description of magic – but it’s still description.

I feel like I understand the character much better, seeing his darker side and his dark desires. He almost reminds me of a vampire.

Some of the names for the magical things in your book are very good in that they give the reader an idea of what they are describing from just their name: Manifestation, Mundane, Others aren’t as good because they don’t give any clues as to what they stand for.

One thing I learned from a very successful writer at a writer’s conference is not to waste names. He was talking about character names – such as don’t use Smith or Jones that don’t say anything. Use a name that has an effect on the reader in that it makes an impression in that help define the character in the reader's mind. I think the same policy would work well here for all the different type of magicians you have in this book. Just a "find and replace" idea that wouldn't actually be that hard to do.


The writing is excellent. I noticed it especially in the early paragraphs when you were coming up with those ways to describe smells, and using the other senses to make the reader feel what was going on. I felt like I was smelling things I hadn’t thought of for I don’t know how long, but when I heard you describe them with the analogies you used, I remembered just how they did smell.

Plus, the way the story unwinds is also done very well. There are maybe too many new things introduced in this chapter as I said, but they are again introduced as part of the action without stopping to describe them too much.

I thought the plot was very interesting in this chapter. It left me a lot of different reasons to want to keep reading because you didn’t give away how the story will go. I got ideas of how it could go, but I really don’t have enough information to understand the world to even guess so far. But that makes me want to read on to get that information – so it is a good thing.


CH 2 Those who are mine (Part 1) REV OCT 11
(Minor revisions since the chat- Thank you to chatterbox reviewers for numerous suggestions.)

The smell of their magic was the same: an acrid perfume like a just struck match, a heavy sweetness like cherry blossoms on the wind, mixed with the more earthy smell of childhood sweat. They were perhaps nine or ten years old, all curls and giggles, trying on their femininity by swapping lip gloss in various flavors.

He wanted to touch them.

Instead, He stuffed his ungloved hands deep into the pockets of his mid-length ivory jacket, and curled his fingers around the small mirror decorated with a pegasus in flight. He let his fingers play over the platinum folds of the cool wing feathers, silently counting them. He regained perspective. Not just any child would do. He must find the right child.

It was a new generation and he could no longer pluck them from their homes and schools with impunity as he had almost three centuries ago. One of the girls, a frail twig of a child, raised her dark eyes to his with a defiance and forthrightness that was both refreshing and alarming in one so young. He was suddenly aware of her magic in a way that was infinitely more intimate. Sexta, he thought immediately. Her magic cascaded over him with the sweet stickiness of hot fudge over cool ice cream, undulating in soft waves of power and he knew her magical element was Water, but not pure stream Water. It was the deep churning Waters of an underground river or geyser that promised secret reservoirs of power. He could have invaded her mind though those eyes and sucked every thought from her. He could have given her thoughts that would sear her tender mind, and broken her sticklike body, but he reminded himself, now was not the time for such play. Later, he promised himself. Later he would teach her to offer the accolades due him, and the game would be sweeter for the waiting. He was patient. More than two thousand years had taught him patience.

He broke the eye contact and she, completely unaware of the danger, turned back to holding court with her giggling friends. Even at this young age, he thought, her talent makes her queen of her realm, gathering those of her circle. She ran the lip gloss over her tiny pink lips, first the top and then the bottom and pursed them together like a kiss. His naked fingers tightened around the pegasus mirror, as he caught the sweet scent of banana: such a mundane scent to be mixed with the gurgling waters of her magic.

As she turned and ran for the swingset, another child, a golden-haired angel magically caught the tube as the dark one tossed it to her. He felt the sharp spark of the blonde’s summoning. And he knew that her element was Fire—like Valeriana he thought wistfully. It was no sorcery. The girl had not yet learned to control her element. It was just an exertion of power, a small use of talent, and yet, the smell of scorched cherry blossoms hung in the air, and heat still radiated around her like a desert mirage. She tossed her blonde mane and pranced through the other girls, scattering them as she rushed to join her friend. She gave him the impression of a high-strung and unflown filly. He would be the one to fly her first, he thought, his own magic boiling in hot viscous waves of passion. Even so young, power plays were evident as some lesser power reluctantly gave up her swing to the blonde. Sparks of Fire danced along the ground as she pumped, higher and higher. The brunette laughed and pushed hard running under her friend’s swing. He admired their daring as the blonde leaped clear. For a moment, the swing was free and he, knowing children, expected a shuffle for it, but none of the others contested the dominance of the two Sextae. The brunette claimed the swing as the blonde crouched where she had landed, her magic ablaze. They were friends: blonde and brunette, Fire and Water, a team, evidenced by their unconscious choreography. Their essence suffused the playground.

He would Awaken them to all that magic could be—he would control their Magigenesis. But not yet. He had urgent business in Duriel right now. These two could wait. The Council of Five could not. The time of the Conversion of Elements was quickly approaching, and he would not wait another four hundred years for dominion. Certainly not for the sake of playing with children no matter how pleasant the thought might be. Watching the girls play, Need to introduce his name much earlier – near beginning of Chapter 1Sigerdlic’s body was suffused with blood and magic. They were two buds tightly closed, awaiting his tutelage...soon...

**

“Consul?” A hand touched his shoulder and even through the brocade of the coat and material of the suit Sigerdlic felt the presence of the teacher. He sucked in his breath, and dragged his eyes from the play of the Antemagenae. The woman who touched him knew nothing of his thoughts. He was too careful and she was too stupid.

To have touched him at all, even through the fabric, told him she was only slightly less naïve than the children who were her charges. She yanked back her hand as if suddenly realizing her rudeness in touching him. Too much time among the Mundanes, he surmised. I love this concept of the Mundanes. Can’t wait to find out more about them. She did have at least a minimal amount of sense to lower her eyes and avoid meeting the gaze of her better as he turned to her. She was as young as Karoline, and not half so bright. He wondered if they hired anyone of worth in this office. The entire school was an exercise in mediocrity. It seemed impossible that this facility was the foundation for Duriel’s finest young Sorceri. He waited for her greeting and her reason for interrupting him, but she seemed to have been struck dumb.

She folded her hands in the Salu-manuum, finally acknowledging his magical superiority and dipped in a half-hearted curtsy-like gesture. The motion was awkward from disuse and only the bare minimum of respect that his Consul station earned him from her. “Good morning—sir—Sorcerer—Altissimus—“ She stood for a moment tongue-tied, but he did not excuse her stammering or attempt to put her at ease.

She silently stripped off one of her gloves. He supposed she was apologizing for her earlier blunder in touching him by offering her bare right hand as well as the unshielded buzz of her magic. She did not bow her head, nor did she expose the back of her neck. She did not kneel before him. Only one hand was bared and slightly raised. He looked at her naked hand with mild interest. She was young for a teacher, but in control of her magic, not young enough for his tastes. His own hands were ungloved since he didn’t often have intimate contact with Antemagenae, at least not officially. Certain professionals were required to wear gloves to shield against an accidental skin to skin contact with their unAwakened charges. A simple touch could become much more intimate than was socially acceptable between a child and an adult, but she was, for all her youth, Awakened.

He might have found her offer tempting if her magic were anything remarkable. However, she was only a lower level Quinta, hardly worth his notice, and the polite gesture of apology was just that: a polite gesture that meant nothing to her. She wasn’t really expecting him to take what she so freely offered; magic was no longer exchanged in public apologies at least not for something as trivial as her sin. He longed for the days gone by, when a master Sorcerer could take an underling’s power with impunity, to demonstrate superiority or to punish an apprentice by literally sucking the magic from his body with only a touch of skin to skin, and magic to magic. It was a painful, but temporary condition, which chastised, but did not cause lasting harm to the lesser Sorcerer. Now such methods were only used as a last resort to help a Sorcerer in distress control his magic, and even then the magic had to be truly large and out of control to warrant such action: an ancient ritual of supremacy reduced to a teacher’s aide. Fascinating paragraph

He put his reminiscing behind him. Such thoughts would only detract from his goal and this was not the only magic bastardized by the Rift. Much of such great magic invoked by touch or gaze alone had been lost. Sorceri were more civilized now. They kept to their own bodies, at least in polite company, mores the pity.

To rebuke her in the old way, as he wished, would draw too much attention. Instead, the Consul simply brushed his aura against hers in polite acknowledgement of her apology as she expected. “Nihil est.”

The Quinta relaxed as he took his hands from the dominant position above hers.

He returned her deficient greeting with his own, instructing her by example, acknowledging her power level, five, and her status, aid to the teacher of children. “Salve, Quinta, Submagistra liberorum.”

“Thank you,” she said. “I didn’t know you were a magic sensor, Consul.”

“Your magic level is on file,” he said blandly, and it was, although she was correct that he had read her level of magic directly from her. However, he wasn’t a magic sensor. He was so much more. “Nonetheless,” he continued, “if you go about touching people you had better expect to let loose more secrets than you wish to share.”

She blushed, her pale ears coloring around the various gems that decorated the lobes. All contained reservoirs of magic. “I did apologize,” she protested.

“So you did. Let’s put it behind us.”

“You won’t tell Magus Magister?” she said half question, half hope.

“No child, I will not tell Jonathan of your breech of protocol,” he said. Indeed, the less contact he had with Jonathan, the better. It pained him to hear the man referred to as a teacher of magic at all, much less as the Director of this particular school. The Consul acknowledged him as Sextus but that was all.

His attention strayed momentarily back to the two girls, remembering their magic for future reference. He could still feel the baby play of power between them, sweet and heady. He smiled. He would have them both. The thought of their Magigenesis excited him. His inner magic stirred in anticipation.

“Thank you, Consul.” The Aide turned away, walking into the Administration building and expecting him to follow her as if he were Quartus. He controlled his ire as she continued speaking. “We didn’t expect you so early. I don’t believe the budget committee has arrived yet. The meeting isn’t until 9:00 and Sextissima Karoline was called out on an emergency.”

“Emergency?” A stab of anger shot through him. How dare Karoline keep him waiting! What could be so important that she would keep him waiting? She did not bow and scrape to these pompous bureaucrats. She was his creature. His and his alone.

“I have come specifically to meet with Karoline,” the Consul said evenly. He continued without waiting for an answer. “Hers is not the only program requesting additional funding from the Quinque Consulem.” he added to keep up the pretense that he was simply here to attend the budget meeting as an emissary of the Council of Five.

“I understand, but her absence couldn’t be helped. There were two magical incidents last night which warranted observation and documentation.”

This news gained his attention. “Someone new?” he asked blandly.

“No. The girl has seen auras since she was four, but this was her first magical event of note. The Bureau listed it as probable Manifestation. Another intriguing concept introduced. He dismissed her and the further explanation. For this, girl child Karoline would not have kept him waiting.

“And the other?”

“Sexual expression.”

He nodded. It was not uncommon to expend magical energy in a moment of passion. Again, no reason that he could see, why Karoline would keep him waiting. “Was the sexual expression a Manifestation as well?” he asked.

“I don’t know. Magnus Magister has the paperwork, along with the budget meeting agenda,” the Quinta said. “He isn’t here either—a Bureau of Magigenesis matter.”

He hid his annoyance with the stage smile that had gotten him the position of Consul in the first place, and would one day soon facilitate his ascending to the rank of Regaltissimus. The hierarchy is becoming clearer now. “I won’t need Jonathan,” he said. Indeed, he would never have need of the drooling idiot. The sycophant had no idea how to teach Antemageni to be strong. He would have pampered them all into sniveling Mundanes if The Quinque Consulem did not forbid it.

Jonathan had lived too long in the Mundane world and garnered a whole plethora of useless psychobabble that would never--could never--be applied to Sorceri. Nonetheless, Jonathan had aspired to a place of power as Director of the Bureau of Magigenesis, and for the time being, Jonathan would have to be endured. Mentally though, Sigerdlic added him to his rather long list of people that required elimination; this incompetent was quickly gaining a place on the list too with her inane babble. It was a fortunate thing for the Quinta that he wasn’t required to work with her daily.

“Did Karoline leave the formalities for my perusal?”

She looked at him blankly. “Pardon?”

Stupid as well as careless and rude, he thought. “Paperwork?” He said, although strictly speaking most of the information would be magical or on the computerTheir world is based on our world. You might want to give a short explanation – a paragraph or less – to come up with some reason for this to occur.
Just something to make a weak or both, and therefore not paper. Such misnomers annoyed him.

“Oh, I’m sure I don’t know.”

Where did they find these malingerers? He thought. The bureaucrats had to seek out people who were so grossly incompetent. Surely, they couldn’t just appear in such droves by mere chance. Were Sorceri no longer running this world? He clenched his magic tightly in his hands and smiled at her.

The woman continued speaking, “Sextissima Karoline said she would be back before you arrived, but you might be interested to know, that the child she went to observe has been seeing auras since age four.[c:green} You said this already in slightly different words earlier. We have been watching her, waiting for her Manifestation…”

We, meaning the Bureau of Magigenesis, Sigerdlic thought, not his organization. Mentally, he tuned the Quinta out. He was not interested in the little Antemagena aura seer that she was telling him about. He was indifferent to Mundane born Antemagenae unless they also claimed Sextus level magic. He did not think that Karoline would have the audacity to keep him waiting while she surveyed the aura seer. No. It was something else, something she had not told this young Quinta.

The Quinta’s words brought him back from his reverie.

“I just think something should be done about the Mundane parents when the child is so obviously magical and they refuse to believe. Why just last week we practically had to rescue a young prophetess from her own family. They thought that they could starve or beat the devil out of her—the poor child. I tell you something should be done--”

”Indeed,” he agreed. “Strychnine is effective.”

She looked at him for a moment and then laughed nervously. “You’re joking of course.”

The Consul smiled. “Of course.” There were much more efficient ways of magically killing the Mundane parents, when they were problematic, and their life forces could then be put to better use.

There was a moment of tense silence before the Quinta gestured to the door at the end of the corridor. Sigerdlic had the distinct impression that she was anxious to be out of his company. She wasn’t the first to feel that way.

“You can wait in Sextissima Karoline’s office if you like,” she said.

Like? He thought. No, he didn’t like it, but railing at this underling would gain nothing. “That will be adequate,” he said. He waved a nonchalant hand at her dismissing her, but she remained.

“Is there anything else you require, Sir?”

“No. You are dismissed,” he said coldly.

She bristled slightly and he remembered that even such useless underlings required polite civility in this century. He had been too long removed from such contact. He forgot the peons here considered themselves equal in the manner of certain Mundanes. Could they not remember they were Sorceri and thus unbound by Mundane law?

He smiled at her, correcting his oversight by exuding good will and charisma. She relaxed an inane smile on her thin lips. Yes, she definitely belonged on his elimination list. She was too stupid to live.

“I’m sure Sextissima Karoline won’t be long,” the Quinta aid told the Consul. “She has a water pitcher in the room. Shall I bring you some coffee or tea, Consul?”

Sigerdlic declined the drink, finally relieving himself of the useless chattel, and spent precisely seventeen minutes in Karoline’s office perusing her files and records: magical, digital and paper, trying to piece together what Karoline had found that would be of interest to him. It wouldn’t have been the two little girls. They were probable Sextae, an interesting diversion, but not of pressing importance or political concern. Karoline wouldn’t have asked the Consul to come on such short notice for them. She knew better. Only some breech of security or the prophecy could have been important enough. Mentally he went over the assassination plans which were in their infancy. Not enough had been decided to warrant a security risk. Those of his own who knew were irreproachable. Perhaps it was some problem in his quest for Regaltissimus that might be best dealt with at this early stage and thus precipitated her haste. If so, she should be here. No, the more he thought about it, the more Sigerdlic concluded that she wouldn’t have kept him waiting for a breech of security of any kind. She was too well-trained. She would have dealt with it, and later met with him to rule out any further problems. That left the prophecy. Great way to end a chapter. Leaves a lot for the reader to want to read on.

BTW - I hate giving reviews numbers to try to say how the chapters rate on a scale of 1 to 5. I don't feel like there's any way I can make this kind of evaluation accurately, and since I can't post replies without giving them a number, I just guess at a number to give them. But the number ratings I give mean nothing to me, so I hope you don't take them to mean anything to you either.

Dave
2
2
Review by David Gere Author IconMail Icon
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
I thought this was a pretty clear and wise poem. I thought the alternating points of view in the different stanzas made sharp contrasts between the results of rebounding or waiting until you heal.

I don't know much about poetry but I know I understood this one and also it rhymed which I was glad about. Good job.
3
3
Review by David Gere Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 18+ | (4.5)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **


This is a great start to a story that promises a lot. I felt the post-nuclear world as if it were real. It was believeable. I like the mix of characters it has. One thing I don't understand is how she could live in a castle like that and have to worry about all those billls - the cable being shut off and all. Maybe you should say what the owners of the castle do for a living or how they support themselves.

I like the way the characters are not so surprised and griefl-stricken by the war they can't function. It seems more realistic the way you did it where they clicked into emergency mode and saved the grieving for later.

If I had more time - the time to read all the books on this site and all the books I have lined up to read on my shelf at home, I would like to read this book. It has its own way of being entertaining. I think you have developed a voice and a style of your own. Good job.

4
4
Review by David Gere Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (4.0)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

This is pretty funny. I didn't get it at first anymore than the lady (you?) checking the plants. I got a kick out of it.
5
5
Review of Pepper Kisses  Open in new Window.
Review by David Gere Author IconMail Icon
Rated: ASR | (4.5)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **

I thought this was a very happy story. The maturity of writing seems much higher than what you’re biography described. You made Jim into a very real man who has a sad life but also has the ability to rise above his station and situation in life. What I felt about him was that he felt like others would see him as a less-than due to his job, and lack of marriage and kids, but he saw himself as a winner. He seemed adjusted to his lot in life, but still disagreed with it. This made him a very likable character in my eyes.

The ending was happy too, whether it could really happen or not. It’s the kind of ending that happened on a happy note where I at least didn’t really care whether it was likely to happen – but instead liked it because it resolved everything and wrapped it all up for me.

The only mistakes I found were of the following type:

In the following you switched Points of View from Jim to the mother.

This janitor was handsome and kind


You also did it in other places:
6
6
Review by David Gere Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Wow! I loved this. You are a very good writer. I couldn't see any grammar or spelling mistakes. You communicated well in a straight-forward fashion without going overboard in either dialog or description so that it distracted me from reading the story.

I was definitely left wanting to read more. The monster reminds me of Frankenstein. I'm guessing that's what you want or where you got the idea.
Like Frankenstein, the monster is so horrible I get a little bit of desire to have her killed even if she had come from a little girl. It seems easier to dispose of her than to carry her baggage around with her.
7
7
Review by David Gere Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
I loved this. I am checking out sci-fi/fantasy stories for an assignment in a class I am taking to see if I could find examples which were either clichest or one showing great creative initiative. I think this one chose great creative initiative.

Actually, what you did here was make your own slant on a situation that has been done over and over again. But the descriptions you gave and the world you built makes it unique to me. It's impossible to come up with anything completely unique. All most of us mortal writers can do is make our own extrapolation on something some other writer has done.

I loved the detail. You managed to give an overview of the city in story form. A lot of new writers write the prologue (or some even the whole book) as told by a narrator. It's much better the way you did it - from the vantage point of a character inside the action of the scene.

I thought your details were fantastic. I could smell and taste and see the whole trashed out New York City. It was smart to start out with New York City because most people have an idea of what NYC looked like before so it helps us see what it looks like after your crash.

Great job.
8
8
Review of Experiment One  Open in new Window.
Review by David Gere Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (4.5)
This is a little cliche'ish but you did an excellent job with it and it is so well-written and well-done, I can forgive the fact that I could guess the ending. I really enjoyed it and found no mistakes. I gave it a 4.5 because I think it is as good now as you need it for whatever purpose you want to use it for. But I think there is still a little room to make it better if you want to be a real perfectionist.

I think it might have been neat to give more information on the creatures who ran the experiment - maybe make them some kind of god or tell us more about them and why they did the experiment in the first place. Why did they need to know whether the colony survived? Was it just scientific interest the way an experiment in our world is done, or was there a bigger purpose. I think you should give a little more background on what they are trying to learn or prove and why.
9
9
Review of PURPLE BUTTERFLY  Open in new Window.
Review by David Gere Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (5.0)
Wow! That's intense. This is the kind of poetry I like. Kind of like a short story in that it has a plot, a beginning, a middle and a conclusion. There is also tension and pace here, as you did not introduce the purple butterfly to soon.

Another thing you did well was you did not make the mistake of foreshadowing too much, or even at all. In this kind of piece, chronology is everything. The ending does not make me sad. It's more like making her feel validated in my eyes.

Anyway, I can't think of anyway to improve it.

*Smile* Dave
10
10
Review of Untitled  Open in new Window.
Review by David Gere Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (4.5)
I really like this piece. It keeps building and building the tension. I guess I was kind of hoping for someone (thing) to jump out of the woods at the end.

I liked the way you showed the relationship between Alex and Ben, with Alex not getting mad at Ben when he made 4 year old mistakes. I also was really glad the father did not get mad at Ben when he went in the woods.

This piece was more of a mainstream piece than I am used to because I always want things resolved in a literal way at the end.

A couple of things I noticed:

One) We don't understand the time and place of the story, that it took place on the American frontier sometime in the 1700's or 1800s until half way through the story.

2) It doesn't start clearly. It gets off to kind of a confusing start, making it hard to get into it until you've read on a few paragraphs.

You did great though. Those are only minor things.

Dave
11
11
Review by David Gere Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (4.5)
Hmmm! A little prejudiced against men, huh? Oh well! A lot of women are that way so I'm not too shocked.

It tells a lot about a culture for a parent to give away a child because it is a girl and not a boy. I wonder if at some time in history parents valued girls more than boys because the challenge was to have as many children as you could, with the population problem opposite of the way it is today.

Your grandma is a good writer. Her story makes a good short story and sheds a light on the culture she lived in at the time she wrote this. I could really feel what it was like in the woods with her, especially with her throwing the leaves in the river.
12
12
Review by David Gere Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 18+ | (5.0)
Really fascinating stuff. I've never heard an account of Viet Nam from a black man's point of view. The combat scenes were an eye-opener. I felt like I was there.

This rised topical interest. Especially when Obama is trying to resurrect the civil rights movement.

Great job.

Dave
13
13
Review of Last ride  Open in new Window.
Review by David Gere Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
You did a great job for a first piece. It was well written and developed well. Personally, I hate those endings where you don't know what happened; the reader is left hanging - but on the other hand I know a lot of writers like writing this kind of story and it is regarded as good writing in mainstream fiction.

The only thing I thought you should work on is maybe the order you put things in in the story. I'm not sure but I thought some of the events were not in chronological order. You should never refer to an event before it happens and then have it happen afterwards because that takes the tension and suspense out of it. I don't know if you did that or not. Go back and check it out.

The other thing you could change is to start it with more of a hook, maybe saying something about him carrying a revolver or something. With a hook at the beginning of the story it is okay to foreshadow.

But all in all, this is a very good job. Every good story needs to be rewritten and if you do the same you will have a really good story here. I edit the chapters of my book running off the edits as many fifteen times in the process of making small changes. So get used to the necessity of editing. I've been told by an editor that 10% of a successful story or manuscript is the writing, 10% the promotion and the other 80% editing.

I doubt if you are serious enough with this story to spend that much time on it; I'd only do it if you want to submit it and try to get it published. But it is well written and I think you did a very good job and have a very good future as a writer.

*Smile* David Gere
14
14
Review by David Gere Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (4.5)
I try to go back, eventually, and review everyone who has reviewed me. I missed yours and just found it in my Chapter 10 Used Reviews folder. So I checked this out and am glad I did.

You write well. And for just a prologue you make me want to read more. The only thing I would suggest is to tag more of the dialog (say who's saying what so as not to confuse the reader ). I will add you to my favorites and gradually review your book.



15
15
Review by David Gere Author IconMail Icon
Rated: ASR | (5.0)
I loved this. I'm a guy but it made perfect sense to me. This kind of stuff goes around in relationships for both men and women I guess. I thought he was going to break up with her at first but he ended up just trying to keep the relationship without anything he did being a big deal.

I like this kind of poetry. It's easier to read and make sense of if it rhymes. Good job.
16
16
Review of Pressure  Open in new Window.
Review by David Gere Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (4.5)
This is a true story for baseball fans. How true to life is it? I mean the Astros and the White Sox met in the Series a couple of years ago. Did you know anyone from those teams? This sounds like it could have been from a personal experience.

It is well-written mainstream fiction. I wrote something about Little League on my portfolio but it is nothing like this. Good job.

17
17
Review by David Gere Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (5.0)
I really like this now. I like having the girl along too - and having her a thief is a great touch. It's like giving her a special power. I also thought it was funny that the dwarf was unhappy about not being able to get a beer.

This is by far your best chapter yet. Keep going with it.


Cut this stuff out at this point:

Countless battles, endless adventure and terrifying revelations faced them as they fearlessly walked out of the safety of Eshuston and onto the old, beaten path which led north, to Esaed-t'i'ra-nor. To their destinies.

You don't want the narrator to tell the reader what is going to happen. You want the story told through the character's point of view as much as possible as seen through the character's eyes. When you use a narrator, you can only narrate things the characters can experience in the world they live in which you make up.
18
18
Review by David Gere Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (4.0)
The idea is right. There is the makings of a good story here. I take it you are just getting started on it and are not totally sure about the whole thing yet. You have the beginnings of a very entertaining action-adventure novel. I would advise you to make an outline if you haven't already.

If you foreshadowed this in the prologue it would be better.

Also, you need to give a reason why Alaerin does not go get the statuette himself. Is he too lazy or too cowardly?

Anyway, keep going on it.
19
19
Review by David Gere Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (4.0)
This is very interesting. I like the world you have created and the characters in this chapter. This is a good prologue as far as drawing people into the world you are inventing. That world is the kind of world a lot of fantasy readers like - in this case the kind with a harsh environment and evil races of characters.

There is one big problem with this type of prologue. Where it ends it's like the story ends. It's like all the loose ends are wrapped up at the end of this prologue so a reader may be tempted to say "It's over" and not read anymore. You need something here to connect with the next chapter to make the reader want to further on.

Otherwise, great start.
20
20
Review by David Gere Author IconMail Icon
Rated: E | (5.0)
This reminds me much of the series by Piers Anthony - the Split Infinity series. I'm curious to see how you develop this game into the plot. I can't say too much about it now because I need to read more chapters before I can really get an opinion on it - but for a prologue it does a good job.

I am just finishing reading a book called American Gods where all the American Gods of High Technology attack and try to wipe out the ancient gods such as Odin and a million others who are not really named.
I'll let you know if that book tweaks my perspective on your novel or not.

One thing you might try - some authors do this and some don't. Some writers say its better to get rid of as many adjectives as possible because loading it down with adjectives slows down the reading a lot. Then other authors use adjectives galore to describe their world in the minutest detail. You might try taking your chapters and deleting all the adjectives you can and seeing if it reads better. And if not, go back and use the original.

I had somemone in my writer's group who really knew what she was doing and she gave me that advice. I loved all the adjectives I had come up with and felt like many of them were my own relativews I was so fond of them. But when I deleted them it read so much better and faster I was amazed. It just makes the plot move faster.

Anyway, just a suggestion to try if you want. To different folks, different strokes.
21
21
Review of The Last Dragon  Open in new Window.
Review by David Gere Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (4.5)
Very cute. Sad though. I never would have thought of trying to make something out of mythology like this into a fantasy story.

It reminds me a little of Puff the Magic dragon where Puff grows up having a playmate and then his playmate leaves and he is alone forever.

It could be continued or extended or even made into a book the way you ended it . But then Kreylure would have to escape her predicament as what we know as the Loch Ness monster. Maybe it's better to leave it alone.

Dave
22
22
Review by David Gere Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
This is so cool Sam. I love the religious angle. It's like Christainity and then a little bit different in that this could never happen according to the Bible.

It was good you switche from pure dialogue to a chapter with a lot more description in it just to provide variety between different writing styles in your different chapters.

This is part sci-fi, part fantasy, and part religion. I'm not sure I've ever read a mix like that before, although I'm sure it is not that uncommon.

Make sure to let your characters grow and develop as a result of their adventures as the plot unfolds. If you do this, a good book will turn into a great book. Good luck. Great job.
23
23
Review by David Gere Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
Okay. I changed my mind. This is definitely sci-fi. And right up my alley. Again I can't believe the difference in your story and how good you have gotten. I guess I am not giving very constructive reviews because I am not giving enough criticism. But I have gotten used to you telling the story through all dialogue and find it a lot easier to follow. I think you should keep adding new physics concepts into it.

24
24
Review by David Gere Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
From reading Dodge Ball and those stories about high school I can't believe the change in your writing. This is a whole new writer here. It is so good I can't believe it. You have not only improved so much as a writer, you have thought up a really exciting plot.

The only criticism I could think of is the chapters are kind of long. It is hard to read something this long at one sitting. You might want to break them into two.

Other than that I am just amazed at the difference in this and your earlier stuff and the progress you have made. Please keep working on this and keep writing fantasy.

By the way, where did you learn about space-time geometry and string theory? I got a M.S. in physics about 20 years ago but I never got around to studying string theory. The way you described it was fascinating and I think non-physicists will be able to understand it.



It was then that Sam noticed the portal’s actual form. It was cylindrical, and seemed to be made of neither matter nor emptiness, even though that was impossible.->awesome


How do you know this stuff?”

“I’m 15. I read a lot of this string theory and alternate universe stuff. Oh, and by the way, according to the string theory, this universe could collapse at any moment, leaving us floating in hyperspace and the fabric of space and time.”-> I think this with the previous paragraph above is pretty funny.
25
25
Review by David Gere Author IconMail Icon
Rated: 13+ | (5.0)
This is great Sam. A total change of pace for you. I like it much better than your other novels. I think you have a great story set up. I really like the part about having a 15-year-old boy trapped in the Rock. I also like it that he tells them he can have their parents back. This is a really good start for a story.

You will need to edit it of course. We all do. You might want to make this into two chapters where you find a place in the middle that is kind of a cliffhanger to end the chapter on such as where they find the Rock is alive.

I think this is fantasy more than science fiction. Or maybe a mix. But maybe because I write fantasy I think this is much more your thing than writing about teenage life. I hope you keep going with it.

If you don't have it all planned out, try making an outline of the book ahead of time and then refining the outline as many times as you need until you have a good framework of what you want. Then give yourself plenty of flexibility to change from and go outside the outline as you write it.

*Smile* Dave
53 Reviews · *Magnify*
Page of 3 · 25 per page   < >
Printed from https://writing.com/main/profile/reviews/dc1291