The story is original and intriguing, with a cast of characters that the reader wants to get to know and spend time in their world. To watch the relationships and dynamics unfold. The plot advances the story in a manner that is crafted to heighten the stakes and tension from the beginning. The character of Dawn is multifaceted and complex, existing with many layers that add authenticity and realism to the character. The world feels large, events happening upon the peripheral externally from the story, which works well, like entering a story in progress. This instantly drops the reader into the front row on a roller coaster ride. Arms up, here for the ride.
The scene in the cafeteria could be explored, allowing the dialogue and character’s interactions to show the dynamics and relationships between the team with more clarity. This would make each individual stand out as a character rather than a talking head. Let their personalities shine through. Especially when introducing multiple supporting characters into the cast, the reader can get lost in a variety of names without having something to easily assign values to each, forcing them to re-read to get everything sorted. By taking this foreshadowing approach throughout the story, the supporting characters would be built up mirroring their codenames the reader is introduced to later because they reflect their traits/actions.
“And Dawn left the cafeteria. Lea looked at Joe and sighed. He shrugged in response.”.-throw away line, doesn’t really add any value to the plot or characters. Context of action comes from dialogue prior and after. Avoid these filter words or toss away lines, they can hit the cutting room floor and leave room for the other stuff to shine.
Exclamation points are rare, use dialogue word choice to convey emotion/message. Let the words do the heavy lifting in the story. A professor once quoted me somebody who said 1 exclamation point per every 100K words. This has always stuck with me, not sure where the rule came from, but it’s a good one. Placing exclamations or adverbs pulls the reader from the suspension of disbelief, creating a barrier between story and audience. There is no steadfast rule of never using them but be cognizant of their impact.
Let Dawn’s emotions and internal dialogue build layers within her character. This shows the readers an authenticity to the character, building a larger-than-life avatar that pulls from the page. When she is introduced feels more like a list of things as she looks in the mirror. Her internal monologue which follows after about how she got her scar gives the reader a better-rounded picture of who this character is and what her beliefs/motivations are, this shows the reader the information rather than telling, give ‘em more of this.
Clarity and pace flow through the story well. There are scenes that would benefit from slowing the pace and building the setting. The setting can be used to build the atmosphere and tension within a scene. It can be a living breathing entity of the story, give it life. Really dig into this world, the lore, the story, what is the barracks like in training sessions, explore all 5 senses, and immerse your reader in the world-building aspects of this realm. Really paint a vivid scene and milk it for what it is worth, good till the last drop.
The scene with the Sargent comes to mind. The transition hits abruptly. Here you can build the dynamic shift between Dawn and her Sargent, the emotions she feels about Abby’s survival being smothered by the Sargent. What is happening beneath the surface for her, take the reader on the emotional wave that swells and descends. This could subtly interject exposition and tension leading into the crisis of the climax of the story... By letting the reader marinate, build the tension of the scene. Dawn’s optimism and confusion, the sergeant’s terse tone, the introduction of the new recruit, the team's reactions, all of this would make the reveal of Abby being paralyzed and removal from active duty hit like a wet towel slapping your face.
The greeting between Arnaud and Dawn is clutch in showing the reader so much of both these characters and their ideologies through action. Both are realistic and how Dawn’s character would react to the situation adds an authentic flavor to the scene. This is excellent, give the reader more of these types of interaction between characters, it says so much more than paragraph beyond paragraph of text ever could.
Let the dialogue flow naturally. There are places where it is jarring. Natural conversations are often filtered by perspective and emotions, never really saying what is directly on our mind. Mirror that in conversation and be creative with it, you’ll find that sometimes what isn’t said leaves the strongest residual in the reader's mind. Allow the narrative to fall between the lines, like when Dawn goes to see Abby for the second time, yes she’s concerned for her friend’s well-being, but also dealing with a wealth of powerful emotions ranging spectrum. “Dawn grinned slightly. She looked down. "I... I heard for your legs... I'm sorry..."This is played too straight. It would be a challenging conversation for her, near loss for words, the emotion a brick of cement in her throat making it hard to escape her lips.
Once again stories are subjective, and everyone has their perspective on how the piece feels to them. This story has a lot of potential, the exploration of responding to trauma, and the aftermath of that has a lot of emotional play to it that carries a strong theme of how to heal overcome, and reach acceptance. The characters and story are intriguing. The theme of overcoming differences by becoming a team is exemplary and leaves the reader wanting to know if they can see through their differences to succeed not only in the mission but their lives. The stakes and danger are well established with the fate befallen Abbey, which adds a level of tension. Nice job. I am rating this a 3.5 because of the grammar and syntax issues. With a revision and fleshing out a few pieces, this will be a great story. Thank you for sharing and keep writing!
|
|