Dear Kate B ,
This review is based entirely on my opinions and preferences - at the end of the day, this is your work and you have the last word. Please take my suggestions as just that: suggestions.
First impressions:
Very atmospheric, it feels bleak and lonely but not sad or depressing - just like woods at the end of autumn.
Favourite parts:
The first verse, with the instructions to the reader to "wander", "hear" and "roam". You are inviting the imagination to take a stroll with you, without intruding yourself into the picture.
Also, the last lines, ...the pale grey sky
That promises a winter snow
As trees grow cold and autumn dies
You end the poem on a quiet fade out, looking up at the sky and thinking of the coming winter while also acknowledging the passing of autumn. Excellently done.
Suggestions:
In the first verse, you mention the "months when fall is almost gone." Although I know it is different in different parts of the world, I think the changes you describe in this poem happen over a period of weeks, rather than months. Maybe even days.
In the third verse, the line "Silence broken by no sound"; the repetition feels a bit unnecessary. Perhaps instead, you could use "unbroken silence", or "perfect silence", or even "unbroken stillness". Of course, in poetry you can use repetition to emphasise a line, so it's not "wrong". Just be sure that you are stressing the images you want to stress.
Overall comments:
A good start, but it needs a bit of a polish to bring it up to its full potential. Your writing feels like it comes straight from your heart, which gives it great emotional power. However, I once came accross some great advice for all writers, "Write with your heart, re-write with your head." I wish I could remember who said that, because it's so true.
I enjoyed reading your poem, and look forward to exploring the rest of your 'folio. Thanks for sharing your work online, I know it takes guts to let other people critisise your labours of love.
**Outasync** (outa time, outa ideas, outa here!)
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only **
** Images For Use By Upgraded+ Only ** |