Halloween story in progress

"And no one ever saw Rudy Thatcher ever again," Kimi finished in a dramatic whisper.
"Jesus Christ," Samantha choked out in a shaky voice, "god damnit Jesus Christ."
"Shit, Sam, it wasn't that scary," Michelle said.
"Yeah it was!" Amy cried.
"I'd say it was," said Gabbi, "Sam is breaking my fingers!"
"Sorry," Samantha mumbled, realising Gabii's hand, "I just got scared."
"We couldn't tell," Jill smirked sarcastically.
"I have to hand it to you Kimi," Rachel said, "that was pretty scary."
"It wasn't that scary," Michelle insisted.
"Don't lie Ell!" Kimi grinned, "I saw what your face looked like when she saw her sisters head pressed up against the indow."
"Okay," Michelle admitted, "that part was kinda scary."
"Admit it! You were terrified ," Amy insisted.
Michelle raised an eyebrow.
"Sorry, I don't do scared."