\"Writing.Com
*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://writing.com/main/my_feedback/action/view/id/3325872
Review #3325872
Viewing a review of:
When Opposites Attract Open in new Window. [18+]
Pursuing scientific exploration trumps all in this spec-fi story. Entry: Gauntlet finals.
by NickiD89 Author Icon
Review by Lornda Author IconMail Icon
In affiliation with WdC SuperPower Reviewers Group  Open in new Window.
Rated: 18+ | (4.0)
Access:  Public | Hide Review (?)
Hello Nicki!

GENERAL COMMENT:

It made my day to be matched with the mastermind behind the "Merit Badge Bonanza!Open in new Window.! Way to go! I have visited you many times and your stories keep me entertained. While perusing your port, I had a tough time on which genre to pick. I decided on this one because I haven't had the pleasure of reading anything of yours in the 'Sci-fi', Scary/Horror genre yet. Plus, it looks like it could use another a review! *Smile*

FIRST IMPRESSION:

I enjoyed reading this story! I was drawn in by the title and was blown away at how much of an impact it made on the outcome of the story. *Thumbsup* The descriptions were rich and I had no problem being drawn into this horrific adventure for two people!

SUGGESTIONS:

*Paragraph*: There were only a few *Right* And Marla, Robb realized, spying her red cruiser under the street lamp closest to the entrance. This sentence read awkward to me. Maybe a few added words to expand it out.

*Paragraph*: Marla was the one to break *Right* I wanted more action and drama in this paragraph. More of a visual - Marla to ripped her arm away from him, and to hear Rob mutter a few choice words as her marched off.

*Paragraph* : At the ward labeled *Right* The code sequence was long, and he punched the numbers and... *Exclaim* You have three instances of the word 'and' in this one sentence. *Idea* Maybe take out the first one: '...sequence was long as he punched...' or you might want to split it into two.

*Paragraph* : Robb turned his back *Right* Typo: You're missing a 't' about 3/4 of the way down in this paragraph-I'll give you a hint-- it's a swear word. (I would of spelled it out, but it's a public reviewing page...*Blush* *Laugh* )

*Paragraph* : The room was divided *Right* Too many sentences starting with 'he' all in a row.

*Bullet* I got a clear picture of Marla, but I think it would be great to see a tad more details on Robb.

OVERALL COMMENT:

I like the idea of this story and think that there is more to this than just a short story. I can actually see it becoming a novel one day. Even though I know it's not your usual genre, I thought you did an amazing job with this. At first, I was worried about the beginning paragraph because I then knew how the story was going to end. It certainly had the impact for a bang of an opening, but I think the second paragraph would of worked too. Was I disappointed with the way it ended? There was a twinge of ... 'I wish I didn't know...', but I have to say by the time I finished reading it, you did a great job on rounding it all out by not repeating the beginning paragraph word for word. Instead, you detailed even a more gruesome picture in what happened to the main characters. Way to go!

FAVORITE PART:

I enjoyed the setting the most. You painted a vivid picture of the surroundings and I had no problem visualizing Robb at every juncture as he set out on his little adventure at work. Good job with the conflict between Robb and Marla. I certainly got the point about how they felt about one another and how awkward they felt around one another. It all came across really well--it added to the drama of the whole situation. There was also the vivid details on the horrific situation that occurred--I felt like I was 'watching' a scene from a sci-fi movie--yes, I can see it all now on the big screen...*Laugh* In other words, good job on the description of what happens when 'opposites attract'! Yikes!

Great to visit you again! Keep up the amazing work!

Happy writing!

Lornda


** Image ID #1630702 Unavailable **
   *CheckG* You responded to this review 05/31/2010 @ 10:35pm EDT
Printed from https://writing.com/main/my_feedback/action/view/id/3325872