Sci-fi Writers Guild Forum

Hello all.

I have recently been discussing with a colleague the notion of critical analysis of contemporary speculative fiction pieces. This discussion was in two parts: 1. There are few to be found either on the Internet or in print, as most of the pieces about fiction are reviews without much in the way of analysis; and 2. There are not many places that accept such pieces were I to write them (which was the impetus behind the discussion). I find that critical analysis of works can be very useful -- both as a writer and an educator -- because it's constructive to get someone's perspective on a story in an objective way. I also think it is useful to review contemporary pieces, as well as the classics, because it not only highlights authors who are writing now, but it also gives light to our own contemporaries -- people we might admire and wish to emulate.

So my question is this: as a writer would you find it useful to have a site (or a publication) that had such critical analysis essays of works that are recently published? If so would it be more useful -- or perhaps just more interesting -- for the stories behind analyzed to be from professional or semi-professional markets, or both? (Or even, really, from token-paying markets or others).

I ask because I am looking to start a new site for such things, and I'd like to get a feel for my audience. I'd also like to find those who have an interest in writing said essays to have on the site. Right now the thought is still in brainstorming mode, but I would welcome any thoughts, comments, suggestions, et al from those here on the site. As well I would encourage anyone interested to send me a message on here.

-----
J Boone Dryden
Director of Programming, WriteCamp Milwaukee, www.writecampmilwaukee.com
Director, Milwaukee Writers Workshop, www.milwaukeewritersworkshop.com