\"Writing.Com
*Magnify*
SPONSORED LINKS
Printed from https://writing.com/main/forums/message_id/1306701
Item Icon
Rated: 13+ · Message Forum · Writing · #980111
A sanctuary for weary writers, inky wretches, and aspiring professional novelists.
<< Previous  •  Message List  •  Next >>
Reply  •  Post New
Jun 14, 2006 at 1:31pm
#1306701
Re: Re: Re: ARE WE WRITING THE RIGHT THING?
Ah, okay, I got ya. That's another long-running subject of debate. "Are modern stories of preternatural/supernatural creatures, places, and events grounded in truth, or are they based on myths created by gifted and imaginative storytellers from ages past."

I don't know if we will ever know the answer, all though I personally favor the latter. I do know this much. We have stories that date back to ancient Sumer, some 3,500 years befor the birth of Christ, that contain both benevolent and malevolent deities. There were proscribed methods of worhshiping some, and rituals and talismans to protect against the other. Almost every culture has stories of evil spirits or monsters, and the methodolgy to combat protect against them. There are also old tales of the Fey, fairies, and "good spirits." Interesting that in terms of literature, "monsters" seem to far outnumber the "good" supernatural entities.

Many theologians believe such creatures were "invented" by shaman/priests, for various reasons. (Controlling an unruly populace through fear is only one example of those "reasons") Then village elders or traveling storytellers would embellsih the tales and keep them alive.

You'll also find some few who think perhaps those ancient tales were grounded in truth, and such creatures have faded from this plane over time.

Interesting question, and certainly food for thought. Unfortunately, it probably doesn't have a supportable answer due to a lack of empirical evidence. (Lack of evidence doesnt't mean something doesn't exist. Just means we can't prove it did. ;) )
Just my humble opinion. Any other takers on this question?



For more "stuff" visit:
http://LiamJackson.com
http://fallout-shelter.blogspot.com/

"Have you ever been caught hiding bodies in your closet? No? Good place to hide them, uh?"
  • Proud member of the Horror Writers Association and the Authors Guild
  • MESSAGE THREAD
    ARE WE WRITING THE RIGHT THING? · 06-11-06 6:05am
    by sesh Author IconMail Icon
    Re: ARE WE WRITING THE RIGHT THING? · 06-11-06 10:08am
    by Liam Jackson Author IconMail Icon
    Re: Re: ARE WE WRITING THE RIGHT THING? · 06-12-06 12:15pm
    by Starr* Rathburn Author IconMail Icon
    Re: ARE WE WRITING THE RIGHT THING? · 06-12-06 12:29pm
    by Lori Basiewicz Author IconMail Icon
    Re: Re: ARE WE WRITING THE RIGHT THING? · 06-12-06 1:21pm
    by Liam Jackson Author IconMail Icon
    Re: Re: Re: ARE WE WRITING THE RIGHT THING? · 06-12-06 1:52pm
    by Lori Basiewicz Author IconMail Icon
    Re: Re: Re: Re: ARE WE WRITING THE RIGHT THING? · 06-12-06 4:04pm
    by Liam Jackson Author IconMail Icon
    Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: ARE WE WRITING THE RIGHT THING? · 06-12-06 5:35pm
    by Lori Basiewicz Author IconMail Icon
    Re: Re: ARE WE WRITING THE RIGHT THING? · 06-14-06 1:09pm
    by sesh Author IconMail Icon
    *Star* Re: Re: Re: ARE WE WRITING THE RIGHT THING? · 06-14-06 1:31pm
    by Liam Jackson Author IconMail Icon
    Re: Re: Re: Re: ARE WE WRITING THE RIGHT THING? · 06-14-06 4:01pm
    by Private Author IconMail Icon
    Re: Re: Re: Re: ARE WE WRITING THE RIGHT THING? · 06-14-06 7:59pm
    by A Non-Existent User
    Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: ARE WE WRITING THE RIGHT THING? · 06-15-06 8:36am
    by Holly Jahangiri Author IconMail Icon
    Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: ARE WE WRITING THE RIGHT THING? · 06-15-06 10:42am
    by A Non-Existent User
    Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: ARE WE WRITING THE RIGHT THING? · 06-15-06 11:27am
    by Holly Jahangiri Author IconMail Icon

    The following section applies to this forum item as a whole, not this individual post.
    Any feedback sent through it will go to the forum's owner, Liam Jackson.
    Printed from https://writing.com/main/forums/message_id/1306701