(3/23/2003) As an objective voice, let me just say that out of all the sci-fi admirers out there, the fans of the 'Dune' saga (on page and on screen) are at once the most sophisticated and most fanatical. They're not as visible as the "Trekkies", nor are they as vocal as the "Star Wars" junkies, but in their own quiet way, they are more dedicated and more sensitive to any portrayals, adaptations, or changes to the 'Dune' universe. This is severely limiting and daunting to anyne who would even think about trying to bring 'Dune' into a visual medium. David Lynch's film version was met with about 60% approval, 40% scorn. This latest attempt was praised for its devotion to the source material, but belittled for its two leading men and a few liberties taken with minutiae that only a 'Dune' fan would pick up.

However, since I only knew the basic outline of the story before I saw this TV miniseries, I was able to watch it with an open mind, and I enjoyed it very much. I can't really make an excuse for William Hurt (who hasn't really given a good performance since 'Children Of A Lesser God'), but Alec Newman was good as Paul "Muah'Dib" Atreides. The supporting cast was stellar, with the exception of Ian McNiece, who would put Al Pacino to shame in an overacting contest. Also, Paul's companion, Chanie (the actress' name escapes me) was super-hot.

(On a side note, it would have been interesting to see Kyle MacLachlan, the better Paul of the two, continue the character in a film version of Dune Messiah, but Alec Newman holds his own.)

The special effects were good, when you keep in mind that this was made on a miniseries' budget. It's a rare miniseries that can hold my attention for a full 6 hours, but 'Dune' managed it somehow. After I saw the miniseries, I re-watched the movie, and then I finally got around to reading the book. I can see why people are so devoted to the novels. The whole saga is very enthralling, and you can see where it has influenced countless other sci-fi ventures, 'Star Wars' and the later Star Trek films being no exception. Recommended.

Interested in buying this? Support Writing.Com by making your purchase of Frank Herbert's Dune (Sci-Fi TV Miniseries) (Special Edition Director's Cut) (3-Disc DVD Set)   from Amazon.Com!

Created May 05, 2009 at 10:43pm • Submit your own review...