GROSS
NEGLIGENCE
It was
almost midnight, early August, and a summer storm was battering the
moor with cold savagery.
Ed was
hanging half off a cliff face with his nipples scraping bare rock. He
pressed his cheek to the wet stone as he tried to hold on.
There
was a flash of lightning. He saw the man jerk forwards, and swing his
arms wildly as if he could shake off gravity.
He
screamed and fell, smashing against the cliff face. Rocks and shale
scattered around him. One of his shoes shot off at a right angle as
he spun out of sight.
Ed
strained up onto the ledge above. He leaned into the rain. The body
was about twenty five metres below, jackknifed against an outcrop.
A woman
skirted the gritstone boulders on the cliff edge towards him. She
reached out to Ed and put her arm around his waist. Cold, heavy
raindrops fell around them.
'Is
he dead?' she asked.
Ed was
stark naked. She was in her underpants. They were both spattered with
mud, and covered in cuts and bruises.
Ed
reached down and lightly fingered around his anus. It really hurt. It
might have been bleeding. Beside them, a torrent of water gushed over
the edge of the escarpment.
'I
killed him,' she said.
Ed
would be very glad if that were true. If he hadn't been frozen half
to death he would have said so. Instead, his teeth chattered
idiotically.
He took
her by the hand and they wound their way between the boulders,
groping their way back to a rough dirt track.
Lightning
flashed another jagged arc. They disappeared over a ridgeline into
the black heath. Thunder rolled across the moor.
1
Nineteen
days earlier, it was a sunny morning in mid July. Ed was sitting at a
long desk at the Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal on Farringdon Road.
His chin was stubbly; his hair loosely combed. He fumbled in his
pockets for a packet of cigarettes he didn't have. He sniffed his
knuckles. He thought he could still smell smoke.
There was
a dim sound of traffic cutting across the busy intersection outside.
The panel was due back at any moment. Regardless of the outcome, Ed
was in trouble. He was deep into his overdraft, miles behind on his
rent, and was collecting a thick stack of letters with "Final
notice" written on them.
Across the
room sat a middle-aged woman - the tribunal clerk - wearing a neat
skirt and blouse. She had a kind, motherly face, and looked bored.
The applicant was at the other end of the long desk. He was a stiff
looking guy with grey hair from Barker and Barker. His main
preoccupation seemed to be avoiding making eye contact with Ed. Ed
didn't know why. He had no hard feelings towards the guy. Not
really. He was just a cog in the machine employed to grind people's
lives into a fine paste. Sure, Ed felt persecuted, but not like he
was special or anything.
Behind
him, in the public gallery, there was an energetic looking young man
with thick black hair and a notebook. Ed was worried he might be a
reporter for the Law Gazette, a paper focused on every failure, fuck
up and indiscretion by the legal profession. Nobody read it, but you
still didn't want to end up in it.
A
heavy-set man with a shiny, bald head, thick browline glasses and
neatly manicured hands entered the room. He sat down behind Ed,
cleared his throat and spoke quietly: 'Sorry I'm late.'
'Hey
Nick,' said Ed.
'I
thought you might need a bit of moral support.'
Nick
wrinkled his nose: 'Why aren't you wearing a suit for god's
sake?'
Ed looked
at Nick's navy suit with its crisply pleated trousers, and then at
his own off-white shirt, black jeans and desert boots. He popped his
collar, took his tie off, rolled it up, and put it in his pocket.
Nick
looked at him with dismay.
There was
no response necessary.
'This
whole charade is starting to feel more and more ridiculous, but at
least it's almost over now,' said Ed. He trilled his lips like a
trumpet player. The clerk noticed him, got up from her small table,
and walked over. She smiled at Ed sympathetically: 'They should be
out any moment now.'
'Thanks,'
said Ed, smiling glumly. 'I'm starting to feel like... like...
something that's had the juice sucked out of it and spat all over
the floor. I don't know what that is... I'm bad at similes.'
The clerk
screwed up her eyes a little bit, and nodded.
'I
know it's a long process.'
'More
than three months now,' said Ed. 'I feel like I've been sitting
outside the headmaster's office the whole time.'
Ed took
his tie out of his pocket and unfurled it on the table in front of
him.
'Would
you at least put that back on?' asked Nick, glancing up from his
phone.
'I
really hated school,' said Ed absently.
'You're
crazy! School was the best time of my life,' said Nick. 'I was
fit. I had hair. Girls loved me - I got so much pussy.'
'Do
you mind?' Ed asked Nick, clipping him lightly on the arm. Nick
looked up from his phone. Ed discreetly motioned to the clerk.
'Oh,
shit, yeah, sorry!,' mumbled Nick, putting away his phone.
'Don't
mind me - I've heard it all before!' said the clerk.
'That
may be the case, but that doesn't mean you need to be exposed to
casual misogyny in your workplace,' said Ed, frowning. 'In fact,
I don't know why we need to refer to vaginas as "pussies" at
all.'
The clerk
tilted her head in thought and then pulled out her phone.
Nick
smiled bitterly: 'Classic, Ed. Mr Chivalry! Always trying to
impress the ladies by throwing his mates under the bus.'
'What
the hell are you talking about?' said Ed. 'I'm just trying to
get you to think about what you say before you say it.'
The clerk
held out her phone.
'The
internet says "pussy" is slang for the female
genitalia
because it comes from Old Norse puss,
meaning pocket or pouch.'
'That
doesn't make sense! Pussies are both soft, warm, furry things,'
said Nick, smiling to himself. 'I mean, the French call it "le
chat" too.'
'I
think a pocket makes perfect sense,' the clerk said.
Ed glanced at the guy from Barker and Barker. He was
sitting there grimly, doing his job, not talking about pussies. Ed
envied him for a dull moment.
'But
- excuse me - can I ask you a bit of an off-colour question?' asked
Nick to the clerk.
The clerk
smiled: 'How off colour?'
'Only
mildly,' said Nick.
'Ok,
go ahead.'
'What's
sexier: a pocket or a cat?'
The clerk
considered the question, as Nick spread his arms as though the answer
were self-evident.
The young
man with the black hair - who may or may not be a reporter - had been
discreetly listening to their conversation.
'Excuse
me,' he interjected, leaning towards them. They all turned and
looked at him. He stood up, moved behind them in the gallery and sat
down.
'Apologies,
but I couldn't help overhearing your conversation. I just wanted to
add, if I may?'
No
one said anything, so he kept going: 'In Mandarin - if we are being
very vulgar - we may say bywhich means "abalone". But if we
are being more poetic we might say thu?yu
which translates to "garden of peach blossoms".'
'Ok,
what's your point?' asked Nick.
'My
point is that I don't think it has anything to do with perceived
sexiness,' said the young man.
'He's
right,' said Ed. 'The Portuguese call it a rata
- a rat. Sexiness has nothing to do with it. Why peach blossoms
though?' Ed asked, turning to the young man.
'I'm
not sure,' he replied. 'It may have something to do with the
Spirit Mother of the West.'
'Who's
that?'
'She
is one of the oldest gods we worship in China. She lives on Kunlun
mountain, and serves peaches that make her guests immortal.'
'But
a cat is a sexy animal!' protested Nick. 'Pockets are not.
Neither are abalone or rats. And vaginas don't make you immortal!'
Ed shook
his head. 'Don't you think we should talk about something else?'
'You
started it,' said Nick.
'Yes,
I did. As a subtle way of trying to get you to think about the sexist
language you were using. That's it! I'm not sitting here to
listen to a debate about vagina metaphors,' said Ed, turning to
the young man. 'Who are you anyway?'
'Hi,
I'm Felix Wei. I'm a reporter for the Law Gazette.'
Ed banged
the desk in front of him and looked at the roof. Nick looked sideways
at Ed.
'This
guy is a reporter for the Law Gazette,' Ed whispered to Nick.
'Don't
you think you should have led with that information?' Ed asked
Felix.
Felix sat
back in his chair, 'Don't worry - That conversation was off the
record.'
'I
don't know what's taking so long...' the clerk said absently,
checking the clock on the wall.
'Is
it a good or a bad sign?' Ed asked her.
'I
wouldn't read too much into it.'
She walked
to the front of the room and slipped through the door to the retiring
room.
'You've
got bigger problems than my choice of words,' said Nick.
'Hey,
thanks for the moral support. I feel much better with you here.'
A moment
later there was a loud knock from the retiring room. They all stood
up. The clerk returned, leading the three members of the tribunal to
their bench. They were very sensible, very serious looking people.
Everyone sat down again. Ed felt like he was being strangled by his
shirt. He unfastened his top button as the Chair, a middle-aged woman
with a steel-grey bob, looked carefully along the line of her nose
and began to speak:
'We
thank you for your patience as we made our final deliberations, Mr
Offerman. In making our judgement we took into account the
circumstances described by the complainants, as well as the
presentations you have made to us over the course of the inquiry.
Ultimately we agree that the facts suggest that this was an
accidental, rather than pre-planned incident.'
Ed stared
fixedly at the table top in front of him, until he heard the word
"accidental". Then he breathed a sigh of relief. The worst
outcome was eliminated. He reminded himself not to get cocky and
listened as the chair continued:
'You
have consistently stated that you genuinely believed, at the time,
that you were entitled to receive the gift from your client, and that
because it was a relatively modest sum - amounting to no more than
two thousand five hundred pounds - that you believed you did not need
to tell your employer about it.'
The Chair
removed a paper from a manila folder, and put on some spectacles:
'Mr
Offerman, you have an otherwise unblemished record as a solicitor and
private citizen, and have cooperated with the SRA's investigation
throughout. It was, however, clearly contrary to your employer's
Bribery and Corruption Code of Conduct. You failed to record and
disclose receipt of that cash gift until it was brought to your
employer's attention. We expect that members of the legal
profession are familiar with and act in accordance with all
their employer's policies. To do otherwise undermines the public's
ability to trust us "to the ends of the earth", as the profession
demands.'
She took a
moment and cleared her throat before concluding:
'In
light of all of these considerations, the Solicitors Regulatory
Authority has determined that neither reprimand nor a fine is
sufficient, but neither the protection of the public nor the
protection of the reputation of the profession requires that you be
struck off the solicitors' role.'
She paused
for a moment and allowed the information to sink in. She continued:
'This
case falls in a bracket in which a period of suspension is
appropriate. Accordingly, the agreed outcome is that you, Edward
Offerman, shall be suspended from the Roll for a period of twelve
months from today's date; and pay a contribution to tribunal costs
in the sum of eight thousand pounds. Do you have anything that you
would like to say to the tribunal at this time, Mr Offerman?'
Ed shook
his head.
'Very
well. We thank you for your time.'
2
On the
street outside, Ed looked around bleakly. The sun was high in the sky
and the air was choked with traffic fumes. Ed stepped forward and
almost bumped into a man in a light blue jacket. He stepped back and
nearly collided with two women walking the other way. It was like
playing a game of Frogger and even less fun. Ed negotiated his way
into a vacant doorway. Nick stepped in beside him.
'Well,
could have been worse,' Nick said.
'Could
I have a moment to feel sorry for myself before you start with the
whole "look on the brightside" bullshit?' said Ed, running his
fingers down his face.
Nick
sucked some air through his teeth and grimaced.
'Listen,
Ed...'
'I
mean I am in some serious difficulty, right now,' said Ed. 'I'm
in danger of getting booted out of my flat. I owe a lot of money that
I don't have!'
'Ok,
but...'
'I
may have been a bit depressed for the last few months. I've sort of
let things slip in a pretty bad way. And now I've got to pull eight
grand out of thin air as well!'
Nick
waited for him to finish.
'But
at least now that this is over, I feel like a load has been lifted
from my shoulders. I know I can turn things around! I'm going to
get my life back on track! It's time to sort my life out. Let's
go to the office and...'
'Stop!
Just stop for a minute,' interrupted Nick. I'm just going to rip
the bandaid off: I need your keys and building pass.'
The words
took a moment to sink into Ed's brain.
'Are
you fucking kidding me?' he said.
'Your
personal belongings will be ready to be picked up from reception
tomorrow morning.'
'I
can't believe this,' he said, shaking his head slowly. 'What a
kick in the guts!'
'Don't
be like that! You know the deal! You don't get a farewell party and
cake when you're being fired for gross misconduct.'
'Gross
misconduct?' asked Ed indignantly. 'I was mildly negligent at
worst!'
'No,
you were grossly negligent! You knew about the register and any
reasonable person would have just filled the bloody thing in.'
'Oh,
c'mon! You and I both know that everybody does it! The firm would
be in a lot more trouble if I and every other lawyer declared every
"gift" we ever got on the job.'
'That
doesn't change the fact that you're a senior member of staff and
you just got suspended from the roll! How are we supposed to trust
you after this? It's a fatal breach of contract and you know it.'
Ed shook
his head bitterly.
'I
knew you had an ulterior motive...'
'Well
it was either I come down and do it, or send Carol from HR. I thought
I'd do you the courtesy.'
'Very
kind of you,' said Ed. 'How the fuck did this get brought to
their attention in the first place? Somebody fucking snitched on me!'
Nick
considered for a moment: 'I have no idea. I don't know anything
about that.'
Ed looked
into Nick's eyes, took a deep breath, and looked up into the summer
sky. The plane trees were shedding their tear-duct swelling pollen
into the breeze. Tears filled Ed's eyes, and he looked away,
embarrassed.
'I
know you've been having a rough time since all this started,'
said Nick. 'You just need time to process it.'
Ed got a
hold of himself. He removed two keys from his key ring and fished his
lanyard out of his back pocket. He handed them over to Nick. Nick
gave him a sympathetic pat on the shoulder.
Felix Wei
had followed them outside. He snapped some photos of Ed, who turned
and stared daggers down the lens with his watery, red eyes.
'Felix,
give me a fucking break, dude!' said Ed.
'Sorry,'
he said. 'Just doing my job.'
Felix gave
a polite nod, put his camera into his pocket and went back inside the
building. As Felix went back in, the lawyer from Barker and Barker
came out and almost bumped into Nick.
'Sorry,
Tony!' Nick said absentmindedly.
'No
problem,' the man replied as he scooted around, and walked off down
the street at a brisk pace.
'Tony?
You know that guy?' Ed asked.
'Oh,
yeah, sure,' Nick replied.
'How?'
'Oh,
he's just one of those people I've bumped into around the Temple
over the years... Listen, I've got a meeting I need to go to now,
but after that let me buy you one last lunch on the company card and
then let's go and have a few drinks. Let's get shitfaced, yeah?'
'Sure,'
said Ed.
He began
walking, hands deep in his pockets.
3
Ed met his
uncle, Frank, at The George Pub in Chancery Lane, not far away. His
uncle was mid-lunch, tucking into a sirloin steak with pepper sauce
on a bed of mashed potatoes. Ed sat down opposite him and crossed his
legs. Frank took a sip of water, wiped his lips on his napkin, and
stared across the table.
'Want
something to eat?' asked Frank.
'No,
thanks. I'm going to meet a friend after this.'
'I
must say, you look remarkably calm for a man whose life is falling to
pieces.'
'No
point getting worked up about it.'
Frank
shook his head sadly. He looked around for his food and drummed his
big meaty fingers on the table. He was a heavyset man in his sixties
with a square, flabby jaw and close-cropped grey hair. He was six
foot two, and had the stiff posture and cold, dead eyes of a retired
cop.
'Are
you struck off?' asked Frank.
'No.
Just suspended for twelve months and have to pay eight grand in
costs. And I'm officially unemployed now.'
Frank
chewed some steak.
'So
what's the plan?' he asked.
'I'm
not sure yet.'
Frank
chewed up and swallowed another piece of steak. He eyed Ed cooly: 'Do
you need to borrow some money?'
'I've
got money,' Ed lied.
'Good.
I wasn't going to lend you any anyway. You know me, I always say:
"Charity is a cold, grey, loveless thing."
'You
do always say that. And everytime you say it, I try to explain that
it doesn't mean what you think it means, but it doesn't ever seem
to sink in.'
'What
does it mean then?'
'It
means charity is no substitute for rich people paying their fair
share of taxes.'
'Pay
more taxes? I'd rather die!'
Ed watched
Frank chew. His big jaw ground sideways like a cow.
'Good
thing you're not rich then,' said Ed. 'Frank, it's nice to
see you. You're looking healthy. You have, as always, a prodigious
appetite. What did you want to see me about?'
'I
could murder a Guinness right now, but gotta watch the weight,'
said Frank. He sipped some water and looked into the distance. 'We're
flat out at the moment and I'm understaffed. Something time
consuming has come up and I'd rather not pass it up. Since you've
now got plenty of time on your hands, I was wondering if you'd be
interested.'
'What's
the job?'
'Something
that'll take some legwork and a bit of discretion.'
Ed waited
for him to elaborate.
'A
bit of marital surveillance around your neighbourhood.'
'Sounds
depressing.'
'The
husband came to see me - seems like a highly strung kind of guy -
he's convinced his wife is having an affair.'
'Why
doesn't he just ask her?'
Frank
shrugged.
'Maybe
he has. I don't know. I'm not a marriage counsellor am I?'
'Maybe
it's none of his business?'
Frank
raised an eyebrow and sat back in his chair..
'It
sounds to me like this potential client of yours should either suck
it up or divorce her. Save himself the heartache and money,' said
Ed.
Frank
finished his meal and pushed his plate away. He pointed his steak
knife at Ed: 'You know why I'm still happily married and you're
not? You always have twenty smart-arse answers for everything - never
an honest one.' He put down the knife on the plate in front of him.
Ed looked
into his uncle's icy-blue eyes. 'Okay,' he said, not knowing
what he meant. Of all the people in the world, he was probably
closest to Frank than anyone else in the world. And most of their
conversations were like this: a stulted, passive aggressive,
back-and-forth.
'You've
always been way too lackadaisical about everything. And look where
it's gotten you!' continued Frank. 'You've embarrassed
yourself. It's time to clean up the mess and move on.'
'That's
exactly what I'm trying to do, actually.'
Frank
shovelled down the last of his mashed potato, and pulled out a manila
envelope from his jacket pocket.
'Look,
the job is straightforward enough. Do you want it or not?'
'Can
I think about it?'
Frank
groaned.
'C'mon!
I've had a shit day. I've had a shit six months to be honest. I
feel like I need to blow off some steam. I can't think straight
right now.'
'Best
I can do is give you twenty-four hours. I'm going to the club
tomorrow for lunch. You can tell meet me there if you want to do it.'
'Ok,'
said Ed, standing up from the table and checking his phone. 'I
might see you tomorrow then.'
|