Ultimately the girls decided to go with Ashley's plan. While indeed risky, her plan had bigger chance of actually working on Tiffany. Even if the gamer girl didn't have a foot fetish, there was a chance she would like the feeling of having her feet worshipped. Once they agreed on that, they both went towards Tiffany's place.
They knocked onto the door, and after a while the door were opened by an unknown young woman. She had long strawberry blonde hair, and looked to be in her early twenties. The girls also noticed that she was wearing sandals. Her average length yet sleek and sexy toes were painted with light blue nail polish, and her foot was about size 11, however they didn't look too much, not wanting to seem weird.
"Hello, we came to Tiffany."Said Isabella
"Oh yeah, she mentioned something about her friends coming over. Come on in!"Said the young woman in a kind tone
The girls entered inside.
"By the way, my name is Shirley, I'm Tiffany's older sister."Explained the young woman
"Nice to meet you, I'm Isabella and this is Ashley."Said Isabella while starting to remove her shoes, Ashley started doing the same
"There's no need for you to remove your shoes... I didn't vacuum the floors today yet."Said Shirley in a tone that girls found a little awkward
"Don't worry about that, besides it's healthy to walk barefoot from time to time."Said Isabella
"Well, I guess I won't be stopping you..."Said Shirley
While Ashley, and Isabella were removing their shoes they couldn't help but notice that Shirley was sometimes glancing down right at their feet. Ashley decided to do a small test. She wiggled her cute marshmallow toes at the very moment she noticed Shirley looking down. The young woman quickly looked away, and Ashley could swear that she noticed small blush on her face. Isabella and Ashley then looked at each other smirking, they just found another potential recruit!
Once they were done removing their shoes, Shirley started leading them to Tiffany's room. They walked up the stairs, and walked down the corridor. While going down it they noticed doors with "Molly's room" and "Valerie's room" written on them. They decided to ask Shirley about it.
"Excuse me, who are Molly and Valerie?"Asked Ashley
"I guess Tiffany didn't tell you that she lives with her three sisters then? Our parents are working overseas, and just sending us money to live from time to time. I'm the eldest one, Tiffany is second, Valerie is third and Molly is the youngest."Explained Shirley
"Well to be honest, we didn't talk much with Tiffany until today. And even today it was mostly about helping her out in online game."Admitted Isabella
Finally they reached the door to Tiffany's room, and walked inside, while Shirley left towards her own room. Tiffany was there sitting at her computer, instead of a laptop this time.Seemed like she was playing some FPS game. Strangely, unlike in the library, she was now wearing socks on her feet instead of the flip flops.
"Hi Tiffany, I brought a friend and contacted one person online to help us with this raid."Said Isabella
"Wow, you are good at that. It usually takes few days for me to get all others to get together with me at library in order to do anything."Said Tiffany turning away from computer and seeming a little surprised that Isabella kept her word
"By the way, I'm Ashley!"Said the skater girl and shook hands with Tiffany
"Nice to meet you, hope you are good in WoW?"Said the gamer girl
"Don't worry I can hold my own there. But can I borrow your laptop? I don't have one and dragging my computer there seemed like overdoing it."Replied Ashley
"Sure, it's on the bed because the charger is too short to drag it to the desk from there."Said Tiffany and pointed on her laptop which was laying on her bed, charging.
And so Isabella brought out her own laptop, and three girls started playing the game. The raid was going rather well, then at one point, Ashley send a private chat message to Isabella.
"I think I hit the jackpot!"She wrote
"What do you mean?"Replied Isabella
"I found some rather interesting google searches in Tiffany's browser... [Why I can't help but find other girls' feet cute], [Why are feet attractive?]. Seems like she is like us but her pride and/or shyness is keeping her from acknowledging herself as one of us!"Wrote Ashley
"Whoa! That's great! Maybe foot fetish is common in her family? Would be great to get 4 recruits at once!"Replied Isabella
"Yeah, that would be awesome! Think of others' faces when we bring four new recruits to the club!"Wrote Ashley
"Still... Tiffany is a stubborn one, she might not admit anything even if we tell her we are like that too... Perhaps it would be better if we started with her sister, Shirley? She seems to be a bit less self-conscious about her fetish..."Wrote Isabella
"Well it's your call, however I would really like to see those toes of Tiffany's you mentioned were so luscious and awesome..."Replied Ashley
"Well... we will decide after we finish with that raid."Wrote Isabella
Some time later the girls were finished with the raid.
"Hey, you guys are pretty good! It usually doesn't go that well with the group I meet with at the library!"Said Tiffany in a grateful tone
Ashley and Isabella looked at each other, it was time to decide whether to proceed with their initial plan and try to recruit Tiffany, or perhaps sidetrack it a bit and instead go after her older sister, Shirley, who seems much more susceptible to the temptation of bare feet of other girls'...